New Beginnings for CDI, Exec Ed Leadership

HLS Professor Ashish Nanda—who founded the Case Development Initiative, a leading contributor to the Case Studies portal—was recently appointed Director of his alma mater, the Indian Institute of Management–Ahmedabad.

Nanda held three appointments at Harvard Law School—Robert Braucher Professor of Practice, Faculty Director of Executive Education, and Research Director at the Program on the Legal Profession—after teaching at Harvard Business School from 1993 to 2006. Nanda will take a leave of absence from his HLS faculty position, but will continue his involvement with the HLS Executive Education Program.

In remarks published by the Harvard Law School Office of Communications, HLS Dean Martha Minow recognized “the vital leadership of Ashish Nanda in the study and teaching of management and business dimensions of professional services sectors in a global economy.” Nanda has been a prolific case studies writer through the Case Development Initiative, and one of his Executive Education courses, Leadership in Law Firms, relies heavily on the case study method. Nanda authored four of the top five bestselling materials on the Case Studies portal. Nanda’s most popular case study, Ernest Shackleton’s Journey to the Endurance, assess Ernest Shackleton’s courageous leadership during a dangerous and disastrous voyage to Antarctica. Nanda says that the case study questions the meaning of success and leadership. It has been downloaded over 800 times since the Case Studies portal launched in July 2012.

HLS has announced that Lisa Rohrer and Scott Westfahl HLS ’88 will provide new leadership following Nanda’s leave. Rohrer will serve as Executive Director of Executive Education and the Case Development Initiative, and Westfahl has been selected to fill the position of Director of Executive Education.

Rohrer joins us from Georgetown University Law Center, where she was both the Director of Executive Education and the Research Director for the Study of the Legal Profession. She previously served as a research fellow at HLS and coauthored many case studies, including Axiom: Getting Down to Business and Berwin Leighton Paisner: Crafting a Law Firm Merger.

Westfahl told the Office of Communications: “We are so fortunate that Lisa has decided to join us. Her unique blend of academic and consulting experience will help ensure that HLS Executive Education continues to provide cutting edge and practical insights and tools to leaders across the legal profession.  Lisa has extensive experience in executive education leadership, case development and research, and is a wonderful colleague and collaborator. Her intellectual curiosity and rigor, as well as her positive spirit and personal warmth, will no doubt deeply resonate to the benefit of our team and our mission.”

Westfahl has worked at the Washington, D.C. office of Goodwin Proctor LLP, directing professional development since 2004. He chaired the Professional Development Consortium from 2009 to 2011, and has co-taught with Professor David Wilkins in the 1L Problem Solving Workshop at Harvard Law School since 2010.

Dean Minow said of Westfahl: “I’m delighted that Scott will be taking the helm of our executive education program at this very important moment for the legal profession. His imaginative and deep experiences helping lawyers build teams and networks draw on his own experiences in practicing law; his knowledge of the changing dynamics in the delivery of professional legal services brings global understanding of the challenges that today’s lawyer’s must navigate. Scott has been a popular presence whenever he has returned to campus, and his devotion to the entire span of legal education helps students and lawyers not only succeed but also thrive. We are wonderfully fortunate to have the benefit of his terrific teaching and leadership.”

We extend congratulations to our three colleagues, and look forward to a partnership with Rohrer and Westfahl in educating legal professionals.

Posted in Case Development Initiative Blog Posts | Comments Off on New Beginnings for CDI, Exec Ed Leadership

How Law Professors Can Write a Problem Solving Case

by Joseph William Singer

Bussey Professor of Law, Harvard Law School

We all know law professors use the case method to teach law. But the Problem Solving Workshop has adopted a new kind of case method—the kind more typical of business and public policy schools. The old Langdellian case method asks students to read judicial opinions; we do that to teach students how to interpret cases, to read the law, to consider alternative rules of law, to make arguments on both sides of contested questions, to understand the judicial role and legal reasoning. Such cases start at the end when the facts are decided, the legal issues identified and narrowed, and a ruling of law announced and defended.

Professor Joseph Singer

The problem solving case method focuses on the case at the very beginning—before the facts are all known, before the parties’ goals are clarified, before the legal issues have been narrowed, before the dispute has crystallized or run its course. This problem solving case method asks students to consider who the client is and what their goals are or might be, what the facts are and what facts the lawyer needs to find out, what various legal rules affect the client’s ability to achieve the client’s goals, and what options might be available to help the client achieve her goals ethically and within the bounds of the law.

Writing a case like this may seem daunting, but any law professor can do it by following these simple rules:

First, pick a fact situation that arises in your field of law that is both common and interesting and which raises practical or legal problems that must be resolved. In torts, it could be a corporate decision that might avoid potential accidents or it might be responding to a past disaster or accident. In contracts, it could be planning a transaction or dealing with a potential breach of an existing arrangement or a dispute about the terms of an ongoing arrangement. In property, it could be a dispute among neighbors, between landlord and tenant, with zoning officials; it could be planning a real estate deal or the terms of a charitable trust. In criminal law, it could be a question of whether a crime was committed or how a prosecutor should allocate enforcement resources. In procedure, it could be a search for an appropriate remedy for a problem or how to handle ongoing litigation. Every teacher knows many issues that come up in their particular field; all that you need to do is to think about what the issue might look like at the beginning rather than at the end.

Second, choose a client. The new case study method focuses on serving the interests of clients and helping them navigate the law to achieve their goals. This stage also involves choosing the other parties with whom the client may need to deal to achieve the client’s goals.

Third, construct a fact scenario that involves the client wanting something. Either the client wants to achieve a result or the client wants to solve a problem or dispute. Think of the facts a lawyer would need to know to determine what the client’s goals are and what facts would be needed to apply existing rules of law. In writing the problem, withhold some of those facts so that students would learn to look for facts that are not yet known but need to be known to solve the problem.

Fourth, consider various rules of law that are relevant to the situation. This is the part that is closest to what law professors do in their classes. Pick a rule that requires interpretation or a situation that implicates several rules, including those that cross subjects. Pick a fact situation that might prompt a judge to distinguish a precedent, craft an exception to the rule, or to apply a competing rule.

Fifth, consider what options are available to solve the problem or achieve the client’s goals. Think of the rules not as the ending point that decides what happens but as rules of the game that create both constraints and opportunities. The law may prevent the client from doing certain things but may allow her to achieve her goals some other way. Another party may have conflicting goals but there may be ways to help her achieve her underlying interests that also allow your client to serve her interests.

Finally, put it all together. Start with the story or fact situation. A client comes into your office with a story and a problem. That’s part 1. The class discussion would involve talking about who the client is, what the client’s legal obligations or goals are or might be, what facts we need to find out to clarify what happened and what the client wants, what laws might be relevant to solving the client’s problem, constraining the client’s actions, or empowering the client with respect to other actors. Then identify the relevant law: what cases or statutes should the students know about? Either make a list and require them to look up those cases or statutes and report on what the law requires or summarize the law yourself. That’s part 2. Class discussion would entail figuring out what the law is and how it applies to the client’s situation. Finally, think about how to structure a class discussion about potential options, their pros and cons, and how to communicate them to the client.

That’s it. This is easier to do than you might imagine. Perhaps you can start by taking a legal issue you teach in class and imagine how it arises from the client’s perspective in the real world. What is the first meeting with the lawyer like? What was the client’s experience like before the first meeting? Take it from there. Use what you know and you can do this.

About the author: Professor Singer teaches and writes about property law, conflict of laws, and federal Indian law.  He developed the Problem Solving Workshop at Harvard Law School with Professor Todd Rakoff, and has taught this course to first-years since its inception in 2010.

Posted in Problem Solving Workshop Blog Posts | Comments Off on How Law Professors Can Write a Problem Solving Case

HNMCP Case Studies Website Shapes Harvard Negotiation Institute Negotiation Workshop

by Heather Kulp

With one hundred participants representing over twenty countries, the summer Harvard Negotiation Institute’s Negotiation Workshop offered five days of instruction to expand participants’ negotiation toolboxes. To facilitate skill development, Professor Robert Bordone relied on the Harvard Negotiation and Mediation Clinical Program’s Case Studies website.

Professor Bob Bordone

Participants—from government officials to judges to real estate agents—learned about managing competitive bargainers and other difficult behaviors by negotiating Kesnia. In Kesnia, a country’s newly-elected government negotiates with an international NGO to determine restitution payments for a resident impacted by the country’s recent war.

When teaching about value creation, Professor Bordone used Diego Primadonna, a case involving an aging football star negotiating a new contract with his former team for a new contract. The case is available in English or Spanish. It offers students an opportunity to develop innovative options that add value for both sides in a negotiation.

Students also previewed a new teaching tool at the Negotiation Workshop. Available in beta on the Case Studies website, instructors now have video access to Professor Robert Bordone’s expert negotiation advice. Critical Decisions in Negotiation features four pairs of attorneys negotiating Iqbal’s Big Venture, a case about the extent of an international technology license. Viewers observe segments of each pair negotiating, then hear as Professor Bordone meets with each pair to discuss their strategies. Throughout the video, Professor Bordone offers tips and coaching about how to negotiate more effectively. The video, which allows instructors to browse through short chapters organized by topic, will help instructors share insights with their students on skills such as negotiating process, sequencing moves, and dealing with difficult behaviors. This is an excellent supplement to Iqbal’s case.

For more information, or to discuss how to adapt these products for your academic or professional education needs, contact Lisa Brem, Case Studies Program Manager, at lbrem@law.harvard.edu.

About the author: Heather Kulp is the Clinical Fellow at the Harvard Negotiation and Mediation Clinical Program.

Posted in Harvard Negotiation and Mediation Clinical Program Blog Posts | 1 Comment

Conversation Starters: Case Studies for Curricular Reform

In April, Dean Jeremy Paul of the Northeastern University School of Law and co-managing partner Alan Klinger of Stroock & Stroock & Lavan wrote for the New York Law Journal about legal curricular reform.  Paul and Klinger outline seven improvements to current legal training, and we at the Case Studies Program would like to offer our favorite teaching tools that address these needs:

  1. Strategic Thinking: This is what case studies were made for. Case studies that specifically consider strategic planning include Drafting an IP Strategy at MNC, Hong Kong Property Deal, Bingham McCutchen: Combinatorial Mathematics, and “To Hell with the Future, Let’s Get On with the Past”: George Mitchell in Northern Ireland.  
  2. Economics of the Profession: Compensation Systems in Professional Service Firms, From Stamford to New York, The Offer. See all Legal Profession and Management of Law Firms & Professional Services case studies.
  3. Teamwork and Project Management:  Tale of Three Asset Management Teams, Three Teams at Harris and Graves role play, and, the instructional note on How to Be a Good Team Member. See all Leadership and Team Dynamics case studies here.
  4. Multicultural Competence: Springfield Outfest, Seoul Food in Urbana, and Ellis Vs. MacroB. See also the cases on International and Comparative Law.
  5. (Learning New) Technology:  Paul and Klinger are referring to interactive websites, social media, databases, statistical analysis, and software. In that vein, The Offer is a negotiation taking place entirely over email. David Abrams incorporated audiovisual defenses for participants when teaching The Case of the Federal Defender’s Advice. Participants can learn about the legal repercussions of the digital information industry with Game Changers: Mobile Gaming Apps and Data Privacy. Also see our Intellectual Property and Internet Law cases.
  6. Capacity to Succeed in Multiple Fora (in other words, interacting with different audiences): Lawyers have to communicate about the law to a wide variety of audiences. In the Problem Solving Workshop, students learn this skill by presenting and interacting (via role plays) with clients and superiors in large and small law firms, government officials and regulators, opposing corporate counsel, and plaintiffs and defendants in criminal prosecutions. The 2013 PSW at Harvard Law School included Balloon Boy, Commissioner’s Choice, The Case of the Landlord’s Dilemma, The Case of the Medical Stent, The Case of the Lead Toys, and The Case of the Encumbered Employee.
  7. Ethics: Reputation, Credibility, and the Goldstone Report, Hewlett Packard and Mark Hurd, In a Pickle: Barclays Capital and the Sale of Del Monte Foods, El Paso’s Sale to Kinder Morgan, The Case of the Rent-Paying Tenant.

Is there a case study, role play, or simulation that  you are looking for? Does it address one of Paul and Klinger’s seven improvements for legal education? Let us know!

Posted in Case Development Initiative Blog Posts, Case Study Program Blog Posts, Harvard Negotiation and Mediation Clinical Program Blog Posts, Legal News and Debate, Problem Solving Workshop Blog Posts, Program on Negotiation | Comments Off on Conversation Starters: Case Studies for Curricular Reform

Summer Reading: Legal Education’s 9 Big Ideas, Part 3

It All Started With the Case Study

Last week we shared with you “The Four Cs,” proposed solutions to the crisis in legal education. We have one more to consider: the Case Study Method. Let’s call it the Fifth C.

Christopher Columbus Langdell

Law schools have been teaching the case method for well over a century, ever since it was proposed by HLS Dean Christopher Columbus Langdell in the late 1880s. To simplify and organize legal education, students study and analyze settled cases that exemplify principles and doctrines. But in 2007, Harvard Law School Professors Martha Minow (now HLS Dean) and Todd Rakoff were among the first to point out that the status quo just wasn’t working.

Their solution turned the case method on its head. In “A Case For Another Case Method,” Minow and Rakoff argue that the case method provides more “known” facts of the problem than situationally exist. They explain that retrospection hardly opens up the spectrum of options—it is difficult to imagine what might have been. Above all, they point out that our society now has a different conception of truth, one based on construction rather than discovery.  Experiential education, on the other hand, provides agency and teaches students “how to think like a lawyer.”

HLS Dean Martha Minow

Minow and Rakoff propose that in addition to clinics (which can be costly), law schools should adopt the case study method, popularized by the Harvard Business School. These concise, inexpensive documents explain a dilemma from the perspective of a participant or organization.  Rarely are there precise answers, but the education lies in the process: thinking through problems, practicing skills like drafting memos and interacting with clients, and understanding more about human nature in legal crises. Bonus: research suggests that experiential education makes law students happier.

Professor Todd Rakoff

They foresee four obstacles to implementing the case study method: translating the HBS model to the needs of legal education, supplying case study materials, teaching them effectively, and introducing the scenarios at an appropriate juncture in the law school curriculum (so as not to give up the case method, which has proven so useful in establishing a baseline of knowledge for 1Ls).  The mission of the Case Studies Program at HLS is to overcome them all, by creating a common discourse about experiential education, delivering products, providing teaching notes, and weaving experiential education effectively into curricula. One law professor, Scott Fruehwald, suggests that law firms should help make the push for legal education reform, with the hope that increased occupational demand will supply more experiential learning in the classroom.   But as Minow and Rakoff note, educators must get on board as well: “Frankly, many of us will need to learn some new things. … We are supposed to keep up with what is happening in our fields.”

Many of the other Big Ideas in Legal Education are compatible with the case study method: capstone experiences could be designed with case study curricula, and case studies can be adapted for online learning.  Programs like the teaching hospital, the co-op, and the corps would only improve with more experiential opportunities.  And if consortiums start advocating the case study method, we’d be in for a cultural shift.

What is your opinion of using the case study method in legal education? What are the challenges and advantages from your point of view? 

Posted in Legal News and Debate | 1 Comment

Summer Reading: Legal Education’s 9 Big Ideas, Part 2

The Four Cs

Last week we shared solutions to the crisis in legal education, drawn from the disciplines of science and technology.  Particular schools have piloted other new programs for legal education, and these experiential “innovations” have proven track records in other contexts.

  • The capstone: Boston College Law School Dean Vincent Rougeau notes the 3L innovations at NYU, including study-abroad, semester in Washington, D.C., and “pathways” options for students with specialized interests.  Indiana University School of Law Professor Bill Henderson conjectures that a revamped 3L program at Washington & Lee has been regarded as more beneficial to incoming law students—the program has seen marked interest and improvement compared to other schools of its caliber.  Denver Law is committing to an entirely-experiential option for 3L education, combining externships, simulation courses, and clinics.
  • The corps: Lawyers for America, a clear homage to the AmeriCorps Teach for America, is UC Hastings College of the Law’s response to the dearth of experiential education and waning job prospects: for one year, recent grads immerse themselves full-time at a government agency or non-profit, and secure an ongoing position there after a leave of absence to take the bar exam.
  • The co-op: Dean Jeremy Paul of Northeastern University School of Law explains that students gain practice in “the crucial task of self-presentation” through the school’s signature co-operative program. After a 1L year of basic training, students alternate between quarters immersed at law firms and quarters spent in the classroom. Students debrief in the classroom, where they bring this workforce knowledge to their studies and fellow students. Paul considers the model self-sustaining, with students keeping the schools abreast of the times: “As workplaces change, our students’ experiences are automatically updated without our needing approval from a curriculum committee.”
  • The consortium: Educating Tomorrow’s Lawyers sees power in collaboration.  ETL, a consortium of 23 law schools staffed by the University of Denver Institute for the Advancement of the American Legal System, is committed to upholding the Carnegie recommendations for the future of legal education.  The Carnegie Educating Lawyers Report of 2007 suggested three forms of “apprenticeship” that a complete legal education should include: doctrinal analysis, skill-building, and professional identity. Ominously, the Report proclaims that “in their all-consuming first year, students are told to set aside their desire for justice.” ETL’s  most notable success is a commitment to funding “integrative” learning approaches, compared to non-ETL schools.

Some of these efforts have been subject to scholastic pushback.  For example, Professor Henderson argues that institutions lack the unity of purpose to effect these changes, even if they all band together. The monetary investments of elite institutions have become the “gold standard,” but it is the intellectual investments that will change learning outcomes. Professors who received top-tier education and schools seeking a spot in the top tier sustain this status quo, says Henderson.

What do you think: have we found the solutions, or are these proposals doomed to fail? Can legal education borrow best practices from other disciplines? Are there other solutions you want to share? 

Posted in Legal News and Debate | Comments Off on Summer Reading: Legal Education’s 9 Big Ideas, Part 2

Summer Reading: Legal Education’s 9 Big Ideas, Part 1

Taking Cues from Science and Technology

Last week’s blog post made it seem as if the end of traditional legal education is near.  But, as the saying goes, every ending is a new beginning. Scholars and practitioners are proposing solutions to the crisis in legal education that draw on the successes of science and technology:

  • The Lab: Reinvent Law, founded by two professors at Michigan State University College of the Law, seeks to save the legal industry through improved education and critical thinking. The lab adheres to four pillars of innovation: “law, tech, design, and delivery.” The initiative embraces research and development, online video idea exchange, start-up competitions, and Big Data, with the goals to dream big, anticipate trends, and solve legal problems. Their course offerings bring law students and practitioners up to speed on technology, engineering, and (gasp!) hard math, with interdisciplinary classes such as Virtual Law Practice, Quantitative Methods for Lawyers, and Entrepreneurial Lawyering.
  • The “Teaching Hospital”:  According to Washington & Lee Law Professor James Moliterno, legal education has become far more esoteric and estranged from praxis than medical education: “a fateful choice [was] made 130 years ago:  medical schools decided that their mission would be to turn out doctors, while law schools decided that their mission would be to turn out law professors.” Rutgers University School of Law-Newark Dean John Farmer, Jr. sees apprenticeship a way to bring law students back to the practice of law. In his proposed model, “Law school graduates would practice for two years or so, under experienced supervision, at reduced hourly rates; repaying their debts could be suspended, as it is for medical residents.” He asserts that more graduates could find full-time employment, and shifts the burden of law school debt to the law firms themselves—eliminating the financial gamble that law school has become. Law firms would save money on salaries and attract more clients, while middle-class Americans (who do not qualify for pro bono aid) could find affordable representation.
  • MOOCs (massive open online courses): Professor William Fisher’s HLS1x: Copyright was the first HLS course to enter the EdX online learning platform. The course was multifaceted: 12 lectures posted online, live-streamed panel discussions with virtual Q&A, and virtual discussion groups about case studies that were moderated by Teaching Fellows (HLS students in the in-person course). The course had satellites in other countries, and admitted 500 students worldwide.  Another MOOC, LawMeets, is a Drexel Law professor’s startup, offering online courses, in-person competition, and virtual problem-solving using video communication with experts from the field. This virtual meetup with the experts seeks to expand the scale of apprenticeship learning. LawMeets, like the case study method, sees value in three sources of education: learning by doing, learning from peers, and learning from experts. To be fair, this wave of learning has gotten some pushback in The Chronicle of Higher Education and The New York Times, in defense of the human component of teaching.

    Image by goXunuReviews, Flickr

  • Audiovisual Learning: CALI, or the Center for Computer-Assisted Legal Instruction, offers short online lessons, webinars, and e-books on specific legal specialties and skills.  CALI’s Classcaster program gives instructors the tools to develop podcasts, blogs, and other technologies to disseminate their instruction widely. (They’ve developed other cool technologies changing the legal universe, such as programs that will walk clients through unwieldy forms.) Harvard’s own H2O program allows professors to make customizable e-casebooks out of a corpus of open-source material—using a “collage” tool to annotate and excerpt cases, as well as a “playlist” tool to curate cases, articles, and audiovisuals into a cohesive course agenda.  Other institutions, such as the University of Missouri, are opening up the dialogue about legal education by publicly posting symposium notes and videos, and, ahem, educating the public about the conversations taking place.

What other tech services, products, or concepts do you think would translate to legal education? Will we one day live in a world with Tweet-able rulings, statute boards on Pinterest? I wonder what our friends at H2O would say about that…

Posted in Legal News and Debate | Comments Off on Summer Reading: Legal Education’s 9 Big Ideas, Part 1

Summer Reading: The Legal Apocalypse

There have been no definitive predictions for a Doomsday, but educators, lawyers, and media argue that legal education is teetering on the brink of catastrophe. Here’s what they say are the warning signs:

  • Disparities in Supply and Demand: Rutgers University School of Law-Newark Dean John J. Farmer, Jr. notes, “Nearly half of those who graduated from law school in 2011 did not quickly find full-time, long-term work as lawyers. Yet the need for legal representation has never been greater. In New Jersey, where I teach law, 99 percent of the 172,000 defendants in landlord-tenant disputes last year lacked legal counsel.”  Now, law school applications are at a 30-year-low.
  • Flawed Ranking Systems: The profession is governed by U.S News and World Report rankings, which, Northwestern Law Professor Stephen J. Harper notes in The Chronicle of Higher Education, are skewed by low response rates, imperfect criteria, and—most surprisingly—ignorance on behalf of the reviewers.  Thomas M. Cooley Law School founder Thomas E. Brennan surveyed 100 lawyers about their opinion of certain law schools.  Harper shares Brennan’s results: “‘As I recall, they ranked Penn State’s law school right about in the middle of the pack.’ Brennan said later. …  At the time, Penn State didn’t have a law school.” Lawyers who participate in the U.S. News Rankings are asked to evaluate every law school, without the assurance that these lawyers actually know about the institutions in question.  Yet these rankings still influence aspiring law students and law firm hiring decisions.
  • Exorbitant Educational Expenses: Tuition increases for these ranked institutions have translated to surges in student debt. Washington University Professor of Law Brian Z. Tamanaha claims that in the past ten years alone, tuition has nearly doubled, and average student debt has risen to six-figure marks. And he’s, quite literally, written the book: he published Failing Law Schools in 2012.
  • The Supremacy of Big Law: Harper rues the switch from viewing law as a career of public service to the emphasis on competition and money.  He cites the “Am Law” ranking system as the culprit, and the student debt as a reinforcing incentive for starting lawyers to seek lucrative careers in Big Law.
  • Pyramid Schemes: Salaried employees outnumber the high-rolling equity partners, which Harper believes has contributed to unhappiness throughout the profession.  In support of his theory, Forbes ranked associate attorneys as having the unhappiest jobs in America.
  • Outdated delivery: John G. Browning rues the antiquity of student-run law reviews (to which Cardozo Journal of Conflict Resolution Editor-in-Chief Brian Farkas responds), which he argues are simply not timely enough to contribute meaningfully to legal conversation—in turn doing an educational disservice to student authors. He also argues that theoretical legal discussion is too abstract to be relevant to budding lawyers. Martin J. Katz, Dean of the University of Denver Sturm College of Law, thinks the “bundled” JD degree fails to deliver legal education who could otherwise benefit from less than three years of training.

Worried yet? The American Bar Association seems to be. Their new Task Force on the Future of Legal Education solicited comments from individuals and organizations in late 2012 and early 2013—recommended solutions are still in the works.  But the blogosphere has had a lot to say as well. In the coming weeks, we’ll be reviewing proposed solutions to the legal ed crisis that have gotten attention on the web.

Posted in Legal News and Debate | Comments Off on Summer Reading: The Legal Apocalypse

Suffolk Law Launches Problem Solving Workshop

Kathy Vinson

“I have no doubt in my mind that this will be the most memorable course I have taken,” said Suffolk Law student Thomas Lessard on his last day attending the Problem Solving Workshop. At the beginning of this year, Suffolk Law adapted Harvard Law School’s Problem Solving Workshop for its first-ever January intersession. Taught by Kathy Vinson, Professor of Legal Writing, and David Abrams, adjunct faculty and former Program Director of the Problem Solving Workshop at HLS, the course combined law, theory, and practical judgment to show students how to channel their knowledge toward client needs.

 In the lightning-fast, five-day offering, students met for five hours daily. The students tackled four case studies, three of which were HLS offerings: The Case of the Lead Toys, The Case of the Federal Defender’s Advice, Prisoner’s Lawsuit (developed by Columbia Law Professor James Tierney), and The Case of the Landlord’s Dilemma.

David Abrams

Vinson and Abrams tailored the student work to the intersession constraints. “All my students had full time jobs, and many commuted from fairly far away, so I had to allow them to do their assignments during class time,” Abrams explained.  The hands-on objectives, as well as the imperative of quick thinking, lent themselves to a variety of in-class tasks. “I structured the work product to include memos, email, outlines, the client interview and an oral assignment,” said Abrams. “Since all students now seem to have access to iPhones and laptops with microphones, I had them record an interview with a second group member playing the defendant in The Federal Defender problem, then we listened and critiqued each group’s efforts as a class.”

No doubt, it was tough—students said the problems “pulled [them] in different directions,” “taught [them] how to think on [their] feet and within tight time constraints,” and helped them “to think outside the box.” “So much information is missing and so many questions need to be answered,” said Lessard, that it truly makes you think—not memorize—think.” Student evaluations rated the course highly across the board.

In addition, the case study format allowed students to face their own personal challenges. Nicole Alfon found the skills of “patience, listening, and, most important, honesty” while working with her teammates. Kristi Panduku said the class helped him develop presentation and client relations skills. For Katelyn Burke, it was about “finding her voice.” The course helped Nathan Carlucci understand how the “human element… must be balanced with legal considerations.”

The Problem Solving Workshop, said one student, empowers future lawyers to see that solutions are within their reach: “I really liked how we did not have to be an expert on the law to actually focus on the problem solving aspect of it.” Seth Urbanoski added, “Five years from now, when presented with a new problem or situation, I will think back to this class as a source of confidence and strength.”

But perhaps one student’s feedback said it best: “This is what lawyers actually do.”

Review copies of the case studies for the Problem Solving Workshop are available free to educators and are 99¢ per student use.  To adapt the Problem Solving Workshop for your educational needs, contact Lisa Brem.

 Is your school using a problem solving approach? If so, tell us about it.

 

Posted in Problem Solving Workshop Blog Posts | Comments Off on Suffolk Law Launches Problem Solving Workshop

Financial Management Case Studies at Columbia Law School

by Rachel Gibson

Silvia Hodges

Columbia Law School launches a new course this fall, Law Firm Financial Management, co-taught by Madhav Srinivasan, Director in Finance at Paul Weiss, and Dr. Silvia Hodges, Director of Research Services at TyMetrix Legal Analytics. The course will prepare students who are planning to enter the profession by teaching them material essential for practicing lawyers: elements of law firm finance, including income statements, balance sheet, cash flow, financial planning, analysis and forecasting as well as the financial implications of growth. Additional concepts include understanding the competitive landscape, business development, business intelligence, law firm success and failure, and practical career considerations for associates.

Madhav Srinivasan

Srinivasan said that he and Hodges set out to design a course focusing on three main objectives. The first is to help students recognize that the global legal industry is large, profitable, and evolving through ongoing structural changes. The second goal is to help students understand and respond to the changing legal landscape through a clear understanding of “the heart and soul of what happens in law firms – finance.” By enabling students to evaluate the financial consequences of management actions, Srinivasan and Hodges hope students will take away frameworks and techniques which will help them throughout their entire careers: “obtaining a real perspective of law firms from a financial standpoint – whether as future associates, partners, law firm leaders, or general counsel.”

Geared toward those in the second and third years of their JD, as well as toward JD/MBA and LLM students, the format is more in line with a business school course rather than a traditional law school course. “In a typical class, law school students would listen to lectures, read law cases, debate them and write exams,” explains Srinivasan.  Instead, in this course “students are expected to be active in class discussions, write case analyses and work on finance problem sets,” said Srinivasan.  The course will also host several industry experts as guest speakers.

Both Hodges and Srinivasan believe that case studies truly facilitate lively class discussions on business topics.  “Since the course is very practical, case studies were a natural choice as an effective teaching tool,” said Srinivasan. Hodges and Srinivasan zeroed in on a mixture of Harvard Law School Case Studies and Harvard Business School Case Studies. The HLS case studies they plan to use include Linklaters (A): Seeking Clear Blue Water, Business Planning at McDermott Will & Emery, and Bingham McCutchen: Combinatorial Mathematics. These cases highlight “how firms have faced a challenge, how they reacted, and how events worked out,” notes Srinivasan, who added that students will also gain from knowing “the current situation in the law firm long after what is described in the case study.”

“We designed this course to give students a new perspective as well as practical and crucial skills which otherwise they may never be formally taught,” Srinivasan explains. “We are very excited to be able to offer this content to students.”

About the author: Rachel Gibson,  rgibson@law.harvard.edu, is the Case Development Initiative Program Coordinator.

Posted in Case Development Initiative Blog Posts | 1 Comment