Unanimous decision against Grokster.
Edit: I have issues regarding the decision, but upon further reflection, despite its murkiness, it’s not quite armageddon.
**
I, the sleep-deprived, need a day off to review the backlog of this year’s SCOTUS decisions. Does this make me a geek?
bleah
yeah that’s dumb. dumb dumb dumb.
stupid corps are taking over America
Actually, wouldn’t that be sort of a professional need?
So I guess if lawyers are only supposed to bill for hours they’re working on YOUR case, then they can’t bill for boning up on new material. Wacky.
Hm, you can actually pull out the “sell out” stamp on this issue because I’m committed to drafting a pro-entertainment industry analysis of this opinion for marketing purposes.
I have to say that as much as I am in favor of Sony-Betamax, I do think that this decision might make sense… They do say that the developers are only liable if they are promoting illegal use of the software. I would hope that this decision still allows BitTorrent to stay legal, for instance, but if Grokster was actively marketing itself as a successor to Napster, I think it’s not unreasonable to argue that they’re doing something wrong.
For instance, I’ve always found it hypocritical for programs to ask for shareware donations when they’re designed to help copyright infringement. But then it does get complicated: For instance, I love my Nintendo emulators, and legit NES ROM files don’t really exist… So the Nintendo emulators might be considered illegal under these rules…. and yet, they definitely helped to spur new commercial products like those Atari console-in-a-joystick systems. I guess the NES thing is also complicated because abandonware is a whole other can of worms…
Anyway, all I’m saying is, as long as things like BitTorrent and the iPod are not affected by this, I don’t have much of a problem with calling something like Kazaa or Morpheus illegal, except for potential slippery slope arguments.
Gah. I hate how my carriage returns didn’t register, so that showed up as one giant paragraph. 🙁
Ah hell. I just think that coporate crime goes unpunished and we punish 12 year olds and start ups used by 12 year old. The private property system of patent law is evil. I have a friend who is writing her dissertation on the hoodia plant (the weight loss craze used by the San of South African to stave off starvation)…and she has told me – patent law hurts people man. 😉