Leaving the Severely Disabled Children Behind

The title links to an article from the Times, that discusses how “Leave no Child Behind” Act is forcing states to design and implement standardized testing for severely disabled students. I could rant about why this is wrong, but I think that the article does a good job of it on its own.

*****

I had a conversation with an ex-floormate last Saturday about a book written by a Harvard grad student who gave birth to a child with down symdrome while in graduate school here. She was married to another Harvard grad student, and when they found out their new baby would have down syndrome, they struggled with the decision to keep the child (right now, I am hesitating as a use the words “child” and “baby” because I know from Con Law, that a fetus is neither one, but my natural instinct is to use those words). She reported that her husband’s advisor stopped talking to him when he found out that they would keep the baby. Later, when she went in for delivery, she asked University Services, if the doctors had felt that she had made the right choice. The answer she was given was, “No.”

So, my question is, is there a trend for modern medicine and for parts of society to push for termination of imperfect babies? Is the practice of eugenics informally taking place?

Finch commented that children with the same problems as my sister are much rarer today because neonatel surgery corrects for hydroencephaly. But for diabilities that cannot be corrected early, are couples simply terminating the pregnancy? Are couples making this decision for selfish reasons, or have they bought into Pete Singer’s belief, that a severely diabled life is worse than dying before birth (as as an infant)?

3 Responses to “Leaving the Severely Disabled Children Behind”

  1. gpapilion says:

    Either way it seems the choice is selfish, and oddly, I think the choice is modivated by economic factors more then anything else.

    The decision to have a child is now looked at as a major investment, and made more so by the existance of effective birth control. When couples decide that the time is right, they are often planning to have their only child, or one of two children. If they detect early that there is a problem, they will consider aborting the child like abandoning the purchase of a house infested with termites. They presume the cost of the child will spiral out of control, since children appear to be expensive.

    The real problem lies with the assumption that children are expensive, and disabled ones more so. This is a product of our current american social structure more than the true economic situation. The move towards a nuclear family eliminated the value of grandparrents as primary or secondary care givers. This increases the cost of rasing children, mainly since free child care now seems to be a thing of the past. Now add into this a child who needs special care, and the presumed cost is higher.

    An adjustment of the american dream would do a lot for this.

  2. […] my previous rant on this […]

  3. […] My previous thoughts about pre-natal down syndrome diagnoses are found here and here. […]