![\"Dahmash](\"http:\/\/www.martinkramer.org\/sandbox\/wp-content\/uploads\/2014\/07\/Defame.jpg\")
“Disproportion speaks massacre, not ‘battle.'” Who wrote that just last week about Israel’s conduct vis-\u00e0-vis the Palestinians?<\/p>\n“Disproportion speaks massacre, not ‘battle.'” Who wrote that just last week about Israel’s conduct vis-\u00e0-vis the Palestinians?<\/p>\n
I won’t keep you in suspense. It was Israeli historian Benny Morris, replying<\/a> to my critique<\/a> (at Mosaic Magazine<\/i>) of Ari Shavit’s treatment of the Lydda “massacre” of July 12, 1948, in Shavit’s book My Promised Land.<\/i> Shavit declined to respond to me, but Morris took up the gauntlet last week. He wishes a pox on Shavit’s house and mine, for different reasons. He accuses Shavit of turning Lydda into more than it was, and he accuses me of “effectively denying” that there was “a massacre, albeit a provoked one.” Perhaps I do, although (unlike Shavit and Morris) I don’t claim to know exactly what happened.<\/p>\n I hadn’t set out to contest both Shavit and<\/i> Morris, but since Shavit relies on Morris, their narratives are intertwined, and it’s just as well. Mosaic Magazine<\/i> today runs my reply<\/a> to Morris’s response. Not only do I question the credibility of his historical account, I also make this more general observation:<\/p>\n On Morris’s principle, every occasion on which Israel exacts a numerically “disproportionate” cost in the lives of others\u2014as it often must do, if it is to deter and defeat its enemies\u2014constitutes evidence of massacre; to sustain its very existence, Israel must massacre again and again, decade after decade\u2026. Israel thus can never be legitimate; it is a perpetual war crime, on an ever-larger scale. So saith the “disproportion.”<\/p><\/blockquote>\n Unfortunately, it’s an question that’s timely, on the morrow of a day when Israel lost thirteen soldiers in battle, and Palestinians are again claiming that Israel has committed a “massacre.” Read my response to Morris here<\/a>.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":" Martin Kramer responds to Benny Morris on the Lydda “massacre,” July 1948. Continue reading