{"id":4247,"date":"2005-12-01T15:16:49","date_gmt":"2005-12-01T19:16:49","guid":{"rendered":"http:\/\/blogs.law.harvard.edu\/formerlyknownas\/2005\/12\/01\/gay-priests-catholic-laws-sch"},"modified":"2011-08-05T14:54:21","modified_gmt":"2011-08-05T18:54:21","slug":"gay-priests-catholic-laws-schools-clt","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/2005\/12\/01\/gay-priests-catholic-laws-schools-clt\/","title":{"rendered":"gay priests, Catholic Laws Schools &amp; CLT"},"content":{"rendered":"<p><a name='a5422'><\/a><\/p>\n<blockquote><p>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">The Vatican made it official in an <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.cwnews.com\/news\/viewstory.cfm?recnum=40891 \"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Instruction<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"> issued&nbsp;this week that its ban on new <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">gay priests would go beyond those who do not remain celibate, but would reach <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">men who &#8220;present deep-seated homosexual tendencies&#8221; or support the &#8220;gay culture.&#8221;&nbsp;&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">[<SPAN><EM><A href=\"http:\/\/www.pbs.org\/newshour\/bb\/religion\/july-dec05\/gays_11-29.html\"><FONT color=\"#000000\">PBS News Hour<\/FONT><\/A><\/EM>, &#8220;Catholic Church Restricts Gays from Priesthood,&#8221; <\/SPAN><SPAN>Nov. 29, 2005]<\/SPAN> <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\">As I have said <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/blogs.law.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/2005\/09\/29#a4936\"><FONT color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">previously<\/FONT><\/A><FONT size=\"2\">,&nbsp;this message seems to me to be hateful and <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">not the least <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\">bit &#8216;Christlike&#8217;.<\/FONT><FONT size=\"2\">&#8221; (see <EM>Beliefnet<\/EM>,&nbsp;&#8220;<\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.beliefnet.com\/story\/179\/story_17969_1.html#cont\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">A Source of Scandal<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">,&#8221;&nbsp; <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">by &#8220;Fr. Gerard Thomas&#8221;)<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><SPAN><SPAN>Although I&#8217;m neither gay nor (for the past several decades) Catholic,&nbsp;I believe&nbsp; <img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/cyber.law.harvard.edu\/blogs\/static\/ethicalesq\/frventalone.gif\" alt=\"fr ventalone\" \/><\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><SPAN><SPAN>the <\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><SPAN><SPAN>Church&#8217;s&nbsp;<\/SPAN><\/SPAN><SPAN><SPAN>position on gay priests is quite important: it&nbsp;illustrates&nbsp;some of the&nbsp;<\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><SPAN><SPAN>reasons why I am skeptical of the appropriateness of &#8220;faith-based&#8221; law&nbsp;<\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><SPAN><SPAN>schools <\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><SPAN><SPAN>and of the usefulness of so-called&nbsp;Catholic Legal Theory (CLT).&nbsp; <\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><SPAN><SPAN><\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><SPAN><SPAN><FONT size=\"2\">Just over a year ago, in&nbsp;a lengthy <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/blogs.law.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/2004\/11\/24#a2788\"><FONT size=\"2\">post<\/FONT><\/A><FONT size=\"2\"> called &#8220;<\/FONT><\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><SPAN><SPAN><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\">religious law schools offer no salvation<\/FONT>&#8220;<FONT face=\"Arial\">, <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><SPAN><SPAN>I noted: <\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><SPAN><SPAN><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Steve <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.professorbainbridge.com\/2004\/11\/religious_law_s.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Bainbridge&nbsp;asserts<\/FONT><\/A><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"> that there is <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">&#8220;something distinctive and useful <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">about a faith-based legal education,&#8221; and he trumpets&nbsp;a &#8220;revivial of serious <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Catholic legal education,&#8221; that is (quoting Villanova&#8217;s law dean, <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/papers.ssrn.com\/sol3\/papers.cfm?abstract_id=302801\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"black\" size=\"2\">Mark Sargent<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">)&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&#8220;unapologetically and actively committed to discerning and expressing <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">distinctively Catholic approaches to law and lawyering.&#8221;&nbsp;&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/DIV><\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><SPAN><SPAN>And, I opined:<\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><SPAN><SPAN><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">If one law school thinks judges must apply the truths its believers find in <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">the Bible, and another thinks that an <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.victorianweb.org\/religion\/Papal_Infallibility.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">infallible<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"> Pope can interpret truth in <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">all matters of Faith, we are no longer talking about a Nation of Laws or a <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">legal <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">system that is <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">accountable to the Constitution or the People.&nbsp;That <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">should worry lawyers and all American citizens.<\/FONT><\/DIV><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">As to &#8220;distinctively Catholic&#8221; law schools in particular, I wondered what the Church <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">could teach American lawyers, when &#8212; due to its reading of Truth and morality &#8212; it <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">has structured its own government as an <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">absolute monarchy, with no right to free <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">expression, no admission of women to its leadership positions, and (as with priest <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">pedophilia) the use of coverups to <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">preserve its image and authority, rather than trans-<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">parency.&nbsp; <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">We now can add to that list the creation of an underclass of Church members, <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">prevented <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">from serving as ministers (and <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">therefore <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">as leaders) due to their God-given<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&#8220;tendencies,&#8221; rather than their actions .&nbsp;&nbsp; [In addition, far from having inalienable rights, <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">members (and all humans), are considered by this Church to be born in a state of <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><A href=\"http:\/\/www.newadvent.org\/cathen\/11312a.htm#V\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">original sin<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">.]<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/cyber.law.harvard.edu\/blogs\/static\/ethicalesq\/tinycheck.gif\" alt=\"tiny check\" \/> Also, although <FONT face=\"Arial\">Dean Mengler of St. Thomas Law School&nbsp;has tried to <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">reassure <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">critics of his <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">school&#8217;s &#8220;dedication to academic freedom,&#8221; saying<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">&nbsp;&#8220;&#8216;<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">[I]t is the honor and <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">responsibil<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">ity <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">of <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">a Catholic university to consecrate <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">itself without reserve to the cause of truth&#8217;,&#8221; our post <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">asks <FONT face=\"Arial\">what the search <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">for &#8220;truth&#8221; can mean to members of a Church that insists it has been <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">given <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><EM>all<\/EM> the <\/FONT><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">Truth, and who therefore cannot accept <\/FONT><\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.catholic.com\/thisrock\/2000\/0009clas.asp\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">contradictions<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"> that come from <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">other <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">Christian <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">faiths. <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">In response to the <EM>Instruction<\/EM> on gay priests, there has been a very interesting debate\/<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">discussion this week at <EM><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/\">Mirror of Justice<\/A> &#8212; <\/EM>with contributions by <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/persons_with_ho.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Steve Shiffrin<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">, <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/another_disappo.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Susan Stabile<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">,<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/gay_seminarians.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Eduardo Penalver<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">,&nbsp;<\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/friendly_amendm.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Michael Scaperlanda<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">, <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/theology.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Patrick Brennan<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">, <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/engaging_the_cu.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Rob Vischer<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">, and more.&nbsp; In <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">addition, Prof. <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.professorbainbridge.com\/2005\/11\/the_vatican_pos.html#comments\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Bainbridge posted<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&nbsp;at his own site and <EM>MOJ<\/EM> a piece asking &#8220;To what extent is <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">it proper for a Catholic to dissent from non-infallible but presumably magisterial teaching?&#8221;<\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">I&#8217;ve been trying to figure out, however, how the Instruction, and the professors&#8217; commentary <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">about <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">it, might fit into the role of a Catholic law school, into<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"> a law school class &#8212; other than <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">canon law, or into an attempt to influence the American legal system through <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">Catholic Legal <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">Theory<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">.&nbsp; For example, I&#8217;ve been considering the <A href=\"http:\/\/www.naples.avemaria.edu\/founders\/message.asp\"><FONT color=\"black\">thoughts<\/FONT><\/A> <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">of Fr. <A href=\"www.naples.avemaria.edu\/academics\/ undergraduate_programs\/faculty_detail.asp?fID=1\">Joseph Fessio<\/A>, <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">Provost of Ave <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">Maria University and Professor of Theology there.&nbsp; Fr. Fessio <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">believes that Catholic <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">educational<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">institutions should be &#8220;places where the fullness of Catholic <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">truth is <EM>joyfully and <\/EM><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><EM>vigorously taught, <\/EM><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><EM>defended, and proclaimed<\/EM>.&#8221;&nbsp;(emphasis added)&nbsp; Is the role <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">of a Catholic <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">law school, then, to defend <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">and proclaim the reasoning and conclusions of this <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">Instruction?&nbsp;&nbsp; <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">Does the Instruction help inform <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">Catholic Legal Theory as it attempts to shape <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">our legal system?<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/media-cyber.law.harvard.edu\/blogs\/static\/ethicalesq\/FrFessio.gif\" alt=\"FrFessio\" \/><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\">Fr. Fessio appeared on the PBS <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.pbs.org\/newshour\/bb\/religion\/july-dec05\/gays_11-29.html\"><EM><FONT size=\"2\">News Hour<\/FONT><\/EM><\/A><FONT size=\"2\"> on November, 29, 2005, to explain and defend the <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Instruction on gay priests.&nbsp; Asked why the Church should care whether a celibate priest was <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">heterosexual or homosexual, Fr. Fessio first pointed out that homosexuality is a psychological <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">disorder, and then explained:<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&#8220;[T]he document at the very beginning says that when a man is ordained, he <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">doesn&#8217;t just perform the functions of a priest. He actually becomes united with <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Christ, the bridegroom of the Church, and, therefore, to have a relationship to the <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Church&#8217;s bride, which is an ordered relationship, you have to have someone who <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">has got that kind of affective maturity who also has an ordered relationship as a <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">man to the bride which is his Church. So those are the fundamental reasons for it.&#8221; <\/FONT><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">With all due respect, I do not believe that this mixture of metaphor, <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">mysticism and mystery can <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">in any way help create better lawyers, or has anything to offer legal <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">thinkers &#8212; except, perhaps <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">as the sort of extra-legal personal beliefs that <EM>ought not<\/EM> to be brought into either legislation or <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">adjudication. <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">In response, Patrick Brennan would surely&nbsp;point out to me&nbsp;&#8212; as he said at <EM>MOJ<\/EM> &#8212; &nbsp; <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">that the question of&nbsp;who can become a priest is not a matter of law or legal theory, but is <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">a <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">matter of &#8220;<\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/theology.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">theology<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">,&#8221; and &#8220;sources of <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/discrimination.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">officia and munera<\/FONT><\/A><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">.&#8221;&nbsp;&nbsp; That simply&nbsp;doesn&#8217;t wash.&nbsp;&nbsp;<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">The <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Church surely has&nbsp;much to &#8220;teach&#8221; the American legal system and its lawyers by example, <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">when <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">it is decid<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">ing on the rights of its members, the selection of leaders, or the due <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">process<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">to be afforded <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">in deciding the status of <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">individuals.&nbsp; <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">These&nbsp;subjects are surely &#8220;distinctively <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">Catholic&#8221; applications <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">of Truth <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">and <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">morality.&nbsp; <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; <img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/cyber.law.harvard.edu\/blogs\/static\/ethicalesq\/noyabutsSN.gif\" alt=\"noYabutsSN\" \/><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">Are <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">they irrelevant to law school curricula and legal theory in America, because they are so <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">out <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">of sync with American values and rights?&nbsp; If so, the very folk who rail against Cafeteria <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">Catholics <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">would seem to be making their own highly selective choices of what to ignore <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">and what to em-<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\">phasize in their Faith.&nbsp; Mike Scaperlanda <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/friendly_amendm.html\"><FONT size=\"2\">stated<\/FONT><\/A><FONT size=\"2\"> this week at <EM>MOJ<\/EM> that&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\">&#8220;<FONT face=\"Times New Roman\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">In developing Catholic Legal Theory, a Catholic worldview (including its theology <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Times New Roman\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">and philosophy) are brought to interact with the law and legal institutions<\/FONT>.&#8221;<\/FONT>&nbsp;&nbsp; <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Explaining the concept of <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.ewtn.com\/library\/Academic\/ZLEGALTH.HTM\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Catholic Legal Theory<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&nbsp;earlier this year, Scaperlanda said:&nbsp; <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&#8220;[CLT] is an ongoing project of Catholic law professors, legal philosophers and <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">others to participate in drawing on the Catholic intellectual tradition to build a <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">culture that values the dignity of the human person, sees the community as <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">indispensable for human flourishing, and seeks authentic freedom for the person <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">within the community.&#8221;<\/FONT><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/media-cyber.law.harvard.edu\/blogs\/static\/ethicalesq\/podiumS.gif\" alt=\"podiumS\" \/> Similarly, Rick Garnett has&nbsp;<\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/02\/catholic_legal__2.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">stated<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"> that Catholic Social Thought provides&nbsp;&#8220;a set of prin-<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">ciples <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">that, if implemented, should create a context within which human flourishing can and does <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">take place.&#8221;&nbsp;&nbsp; He stressed that Catholic Legal Theory goes even further&nbsp;than merely &#8220;applying <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">CST to policy questions or legal enactments,&#8221; but also includes other &#8220;Catholic resources,&#8221; <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">including the &#8220;possibility of actual knowledge about reality, the nature of the human person, etc.&#8221;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">I submit that the Vatican&#8217;s Instruction on gay priests tells us a lot about how the Church <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">views &#8220;human flourishing,&#8221; &#8220;authentic freedom,&#8221; and &#8220;the nature of the human person.&#8221;&nbsp; <EM>And<\/EM>, <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">no matter how it is viewed within the Church&#8217;s hierarchy and&nbsp; membership, what it says should <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">be ignored by American law schools, its legal scholars and broader legal community.<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Last February, the value of Catholic Legal Thought was debated a bit at <EM>MOJ<\/EM>.&nbsp; As Rob Vischer <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/02\/the_value_of_ca.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">summarized<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">:&nbsp; <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&#8220;<\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/02\/ruminations_on_.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">Steve [Bainbridge] asks<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"> whether we gain anything by viewing legal questions <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">through the lens of Catholic social thought given that the range of resulting perspec-<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">tives often seems to mirror the views held by those who do not bother with the CST <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">lens in the first place. In other words, does the &#8220;Catholic legal theory&#8221; label simply <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">provide a noble cover slogan for debates that, at their essence, can be found through-<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">out <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">the surrounding legal culture?&#8221;<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">My reaction to CLT so far is that it has little to offer that is distinctive from other existing&nbsp; <img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/media-cyber.law.harvard.edu\/blogs\/static\/ethicalesq\/podiumSN.gif\" alt=\"podiumSN\" \/><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">value systems and legal philosophies &#8212; not even the current focus on a&nbsp;<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">&#8220;culture of life&#8221; is <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">unique to Catholicism (and the desire to affect legislation and constitutional analysis on <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">the topic is really more an issue of social policy and values than of legal theory<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">).&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Unless <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">those in <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">the CLT movement can somehow make Americans believe that the Church&#8217;s views <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">on gay priests<\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">, and&nbsp;many other issues,&nbsp;are consistent with basic <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">American values and rights,<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">flying the banner of &#8220;<EM>Catholic<\/EM>&nbsp;Legal Theory&#8221; doesn&#8217;t seem to help their cause.&nbsp; Unless they <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">can convince other legal thinkers that the Church&#8217;s positions on topics such as gay priests <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">do not <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">taint whatever guidance it can give on other topics, CLT advocates are going to have <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">a hard time being taken seriously for having a unique, coherent&nbsp;and useful legal philosophy.&nbsp;&nbsp; <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">If CLT ends up being (or being seen) as a <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">group of legal professionals espousing nice social <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">theories about <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">how to help <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">the poor and help individuals flourish, it would almost surely be more <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">effective dropping the &#8220;Catholic&#8221; <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">and working within broader social and academic groups with <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">similar interests &#8212; infiltrating, cooperating, rather than preaching. <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">It is a conceit to believe that <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">others do not have an equal commitment to those <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">causes.&nbsp; <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/cyber.law.harvard.edu\/blogs\/static\/ethicalesq\/noyabutsSN.gif\" alt=\"noYabutsSN\" \/><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">Similarly, &#8220;Catholic&#8221; law schools are kidding themselves if they believe they have some kind <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">of special monopoly of values and morals.&nbsp; If they follow Fr. Fessio&#8217;s plan and see their role <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">as defending and proclaiming Catholic &#8220;truth&#8221; within the classroom,&nbsp;they will be doing a dis-<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">service to their students and society.&nbsp;&nbsp; Using&nbsp;a &#8220;distinctively Catholic&#8221; atmosphere as a<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><A href=\"http:\/\/www.aals.org\/am2005\/thurspapers\/300Garon.pdf\"><FONT size=\"2\">branding<\/FONT><\/A><FONT size=\"2\"> tool for attracting students might be successful; but using it as a tool for &#8220;improving&#8221; <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">society seems to <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">be a quixotic goal, at best. <\/FONT>&nbsp;<FONT face=\"Arial\">&nbsp; As&nbsp;I said last year:&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">I have a lot of respect for the <EM>values<\/EM> of the Judeo-Christian tradition (and of other religions <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\">of the <FONT face=\"Arial\">world), and try to adhere to them, <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">but I <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">do not believe that we need&nbsp;law schools <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">that emphasize the dogma or &#8220;truth&#8221; <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">of any particular religious <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">sect <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">in order to <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">create <\/FONT><\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">a better profession or society.&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/SPAN><\/SPAN><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">CLT and Catholic law schools might be great vehicles for creating relationships and <\/FONT><A href=\"http:\/\/www.mirrorofjustice.com\/mirrorofjustice\/2005\/11\/relationships_i.html\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" color=\"#000000\" size=\"2\">fraternity<\/FONT><\/A><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"> in <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">the law.&nbsp; But endowing either movement with a sense of moral superiority and uniqueness <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">&#8212; or being identified with the Church&#8217;s stance on gay priests &#8212; seems a sure way to fragment <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT size=\"2\"><FONT face=\"Arial\">rather than augment the work of people of good will and sound <\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\">values in our society.&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"http:\/\/cyber.law.harvard.edu\/blogs\/static\/ethicalesq\/commandments.gif\" alt=\"commandments\" \/><\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">today even the pigeon<BR>says a prayer&#8230;<BR>first winter rain<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\"><BR><FONT size=\"2\"><\/FONT><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\">a hot bath<BR>a prayer<BR>then cherry blossoms!<\/FONT><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><\/BLOCKQUOTE><\/BLOCKQUOTE><\/BLOCKQUOTE><\/BLOCKQUOTE><\/BLOCKQUOTE><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<BLOCKQUOTE><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><BR><FONT size=\"2\"><\/FONT><FONT face=\"Arial\"><A href=\"http:\/\/www.haikuguy.com\/issa.html\"><FONT color=\"red\">Kobayashi Issa<\/FONT><\/A><FONT color=\"red\">,<\/FONT> <\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"1\">translated by David G. Lanoue<\/FONT><\/DIV><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Times New Roman\" size=\"1\">&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;<\/FONT><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><br \/>\n<DIV dir=\"ltr\"><FONT face=\"Arial\" size=\"2\"><\/FONT>&nbsp;<\/DIV><\/BLOCKQUOTE><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>The Vatican made it official in an Instruction issued&nbsp;this week that its ban on new gay priests would go beyond those who do not remain celibate, but would reach men who &#8220;present deep-seated homosexual tendencies&#8221; or support the &#8220;gay culture.&#8221;&nbsp;&nbsp; [PBS News Hour, &#8220;Catholic Church Restricts Gays from Priesthood,&#8221; Nov. 29, 2005] As I have [&hellip;]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":94,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_jetpack_newsletter_access":"","_jetpack_dont_email_post_to_subs":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_tier_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paywalled_content":false,"_jetpack_hide_featured_image":false,"_jetpack_featured_image_duplicate_dismissed":0,"_jetpack_feature_clip_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paid_content":false,"footnotes":"","jetpack_publicize_message":"","jetpack_publicize_feature_enabled":true,"jetpack_social_post_already_shared":false,"jetpack_social_options":{"image_generator_settings":{"template":"highway","default_image_id":0,"font":"","enabled":false},"version":2},"jetpack_post_was_ever_published":false},"categories":[2926],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-4247","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-pre-06-2006"],"jetpack_publicize_connections":[],"jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"jetpack_shortlink":"https:\/\/wp.me\/p6kP1R-16v","jetpack_featured_media_url":"","_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4247","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/94"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=4247"}],"version-history":[{"count":1,"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4247\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":12894,"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4247\/revisions\/12894"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=4247"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=4247"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/archive.blogs.harvard.edu\/ethicalesq\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=4247"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}