You are viewing a read-only archive of the Blogs.Harvard network. Learn more.

f/k/a archives . . . real opinions & real haiku

May 18, 2007

cinemas, contingencies, and customs carping

Filed under: Haiku or Senryu,q.s. quickies,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 3:20 pm

It’s another one of those days when there are simply too many topics in the news and around the blogisphere that pique my interest and lead me astray from the task of posting punditry and poetry here at f/k/a. Before Friday afternoon slips by completely, here are some of the things that have been on the slippery slope of my mind.

MovielandSchdy NYC-based Bow Tie Cinema opened its newest theater complex last night right here in Downtown Schenectady, New York. With six screens and a promise of “style and elegance,” Movieland Schenectady has raised the hopes of civic and business leaders, the public and the politicians. See “Rekindling the love of the big screen,” Albany Times Union, and “New movie theatre opens in downtown Schenectady,” CapitalNews9, May 18, 2007. It’s been decades since there has been a first-run movie theater in downtown Schenectady, which until very recently could only be called forlorn. To change that, the Schenectady Metroplex Development Authority has had the task over the past decade — fueled with a half-cent added to our county sales tax — of revitalizing the empty streets and storefronts of Downtown Schenectady.

summer day
a seat in the movies
away from others

………….. by john stevensonUpstate Dim Sum (2004/II)

With posts such as local schmocal and schmittal italy, we have reported on some of Metroplex’s more perplexing investments — including an attempt to put a 14-screen movieplex on the same block (which couldn’t attract financing, despite Metroplex putting up half of the $10 million price tag). Despite the fact that a number of movie theaters in our NY Capital Region have closed in recent years, Metroplex’s chairman Ray Gillen told the Times Union that “A lot of the (analysts) who looked in the market here consider it underscreened.” We all have good reason to be skeptical of the analysts used by development authorities, who always seem to think a locality needs more hotel rooms and another convention center. Nonetheless, living only half a mile from Movieland Schenectady, and desirous of an booming and interesting downtown, I send my best wishes to Bow Tie Cinemas and Metroplex on the success of this project. Of course, I have the (apparently congenital) need to make a few curmudgeonly observations:

  1. BowTieSchdy When I hear words like “elegance” and “style” thrown around by a vendor, I immediately worry about prices. Seeing that matinee tickets will be $7 and regular prices will be $9 — in a town with very-off-Broadway income levels and standard of living — I’confirms my concerns, especially after reading that Metroplex put up almost $5 million (of the total $13.3 million cost) for the building that houses Movieland and a few floors of office space.
  2. I like the Bow Tie promise to never have advertisements on its movie screens, but I’m going to scream if I hear about the “real butter” on the Bow Tie “signature popcorn” one more time. [Can’t wait to hear the price on a boxful.]
  3. The news that beer and wine will be served at the Movieland Cafe makes me cringe, given the lack of manners already shown in America’s theaters. Even worse, is the crowd-pleasing availability of “Gourmet Hot Foods – fresh-baked pizza, mozzarella sticks, chicken tenders, french fries & more.” Having to smell such delicacies while attending a movie, and dealing with their predictably sticky aftermath on the stadium seats and floors makes me want to stay home and wait for the release on dvd. Sure hope those seats are wide enough for all the folk who need a few thousand calories with their elegant cinematic experience.
  4. So far, my nominee for the silliest ribbon-cutting sound bite by a local pol: “If you take a date here, you’re going to fall in love. Let’s start with that,” said State Senator Hugh Farley.

movieFilm

wind-beaten marquee
saying only
“Coming Soon”

matinee
the summer sun
under the exit door

………….. by john stevenson
“wind-beaten marquee” – Some of the Silence (Red Moon Press, 1999)
“matinee” – Quiet Enough (Red Moon Press, 2004)

SlicingThePieF Federal Lottery for Lawyers Shut Down. Private lawyers who are hired by the U.S. Government to handle its lawsuits will have to settle for merely being handsomely paid for their services, instead of striking it rich by taking a giant slice of damages secured on behalf of the public. (via Overlawyered.com’s Ted Frank) Under Executive Order: Protecting American Taxpayers From Payment of Contingency Fees, dated May 16, 2007, contingency fees may no longer by used when hiring outside counsel. Here’s an excerpt from the Order:

Policy. To help ensure the integrity and effective supervision of the legal and expert witness services provided to or on behalf of the United States, it is the policy of the United States that organizations or individuals that provide such services to or on behalf of the United States shall be compensated in amounts that are reasonable, not contingent upon the outcome of litigation or other proceedings, and established according to criteria set in advance of performance of the services, except when otherwise required by law.

one third flip I’ve always believed that litigants who can afford to pay an hourly rate should have that option when hiring a lawyer in a tort, personal injury or malpractice suit. As discussed here, the ABA’s Formal Ethics Opinion 94-389: Contingent Fees (1994) specifies that lawyers must always give a client the option of paying by the hour or a flat fee rather than a contingency fee, and must base the percentage used for any contingency fee on the actual risk involved (of not being paid or being inadequately paid) in bringing the suit. Personal injury trial lawyers, however, virtually all refuse to work on any other than the contingency fee basis — with its promise of monster windfall fees. [In what looks to me like an antitrust violation, California’s trial lawyer association appears to require the use of contingency fees, as it brags that “CAOC members . . . . are paid only from those cases which are successful.”]

complaint bill The federal Government should be bringing cases only when they appear meritorious and worth the risk/use of taxpayer dollars — especially when deciding to use outside lawyers. Resulting damages in the billions or (merely) tens of millions should not be shared with the lawyers hired as surrogate government attorneys. Handing out plum jackpot lawsuits to politically-connected firms happens far too often on the state level, but it is good to see the new ban by the feds. [As Point of Law has reported, a California court recently barred the use of contingency fee arrangements by the government].

For more on this topic, see the Commentary of Jim Beck & Mark Hermann; although I don’t agree with every point made, it is an interesting read. update (May 21, 2007): Walter Olson‘s thoughtful Wall Street Journal piece on this topic, “Tort Travesty” (May 18, 2007), is now online at the Manhattan Insitute website. Among other points, Walter argues: “The fact is that most such suits are dreamed up by the private law firms and sold to the local officials, not vice versa. Competitive bidding is the exception rather than the rule in retaining the law firms, which routinely recycle handsome donations to the campaigns of the mayors, attorneys general and other officials who hire them. Pay-for-play is so routine that it hardly raises even a shrug anymore. When government legal officers refuse the overtures and instead employ their own staff attorneys to handle such suits, they can face bitter resentment and political pressure for not playing the game in the expected way.”

great clouds,
each one the size of
my hometown

phone message
from a stranger
with parakeets

……… by John Stevenson
“great clouds” – Mainichi Daily News, 10th Haiku Contest, 2007
“phone message” – Geppo, Sep/Oct, 2006

QkeyNs sKeyNs Carping not Consensus: It isn’t surprising, but it is nonetheless sad to see that the compromise immigration reform proposal unveiled by a truly bipartisan group of senators and the White House yesterday is already being attacked from all sides. Whether it is the Amnestyphobes (whose one-word rationale spells bigotry to me), the Familiaphiles (who want all family members to follow lawful immgrants and not just the spouse and minor children), the Unionistas, or the Pulse-taking Presidential candidates, I hope reasonable heads and the spirit of compromise will eventually prevail. See the New York Times article “Senators in Bipartisan Deal on Immigration Bill” (May 18, 2007) for a good summary of issues, slogans and candidate reactions.

embarrassed
by the lavish praise
I imagine getting

……… by John Stevenson – HPNC Senryu Contest, 2006

May 31, 2006

“bad for the gander” — a haibun tale

Filed under: Haiga or Haibun,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 6:53 pm

bad for the gander – a tale from the news, by the Haibun Pundit

She had me up at sunrise making “Save the Geese” signs. This must be penance for ogling that waitress with the great legs last weekend. Instead of picnicking, we’re spending a hot and humid Memorial Day on a picket line, on about the only shadeless stretch of road in the Village of Scotia, New York.

Back in 1989, a pair of Canadian geese were brought from a state game farm to our nature preserve. As the flock grew, we’d bring the kids to see them on Collins Lake — sitting on that knoll that’s covered in bird shit today. “Which ones are coming, Daddy?” . . . “Which are going?” . . . “Which ones live here?” By now, almost two hundred of them are considered “resident birds,” staying until the 50-acre Lake is frozen and coming back in the Spring

The beetle I righted
flies straight into
a cobweb

George Swede from Almost Unseen

Most Scotians love the idea of hosting those honking immigrants, but there’s so much goose excrement around Collins Park, no one wants their children to play here, and the Lake and beach had to be closed last summer. Still, the Wife and her Geese-Savers want to stop Mayor McLaughlin from euthanizing part of the flock. They say it’s inhumane and he hasn’t tried hard enough the past ten years to use nonlethal methods — like border collies and noise-makers, and the always-mysterious “egg-addling”.

Except for that one guy with the graying pony tail and Birkenstocks, who keeps trying to start those lame cheers, every male on this line — from 8 to 80 — looks dispirited, drafted, drug-here. It wasn’t enough that I gave up hunting geese years ago, to please her and the kids. Now I’m spending a perfectly good holiday baking my buns on the pavement, not grilling burgers in the backyard. Her crusade has become mine.

There is one consolation: my sweaty face and “Kinky Friedmant-shirt embarrass the crap out of her.

a spider spirals
down the drain —
the cricket keeps singing

haibun by dagosan (with thanks to George Swede for “the beetle”)

In the News, see:

– – “Protesters reacting to decision to gas Canada geese(CapitalNews9, May 28, 2006) “The clock is ticking for 150 Canada Geese in Scotia, and residents are rallying against plans to exterminate the birds. The village is planning to control the geese population in Collins Park by trapping, and then gassing them. Officials approved the plan and said it’s the only way to stop the birds from contaminating the pond. But members of a group called, “Save the Geese in Scotia” said the plan amounts to cruelty to animals [and that “proven nonlethal management techniques are more effective and humane”.] . . . “Protestors also said that instead of killing the geese they should be relocated. However, that approach would not be legal under current-state law.”

– – See the story as it unfolded and continued at Jerry Moore’s School Talk website.

guest haijin:

clouds of pollen
drifting through sunbeams —
a sparrow’s sudden flight

the web between stumps —
a tree frog answers
the pond frog

a white swan shakes her tail
at last the ripples
reach her mate

stones on the trail . . .
a downy feather
wafts in the breeze

by Michael Dylan Welch from Thornewood Poems at Captain Haiku’s Secret Hangout.

droping stone after stone
into the lake I keep
reappearing

seventeen
starlings on the telephone wire
sixteen

George Swede from Almost Unseen

* Don’t forget #59, the special Memorial Day edition of Blawg Review, hosted by their very own Edit.

April 24, 2006

Old Dorp: less backwards! less appealing?

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 8:47 pm

Pop quiz: which Upstate New York city is often called “Old Dorp“?

[Hint: it is the now-disowned birthplace of GE] Give up? The answer

is my adopted hometown of Schenectady, New York. As f/k/a

explained a year ago:

Probably because the name Schenectady is tough on headline

writers, our City is often called “Dorp” or “Old Dorp,” from the

Dutch word for village or hamlet.

We also noted, per Encarta, that

dorp” is especially used in South Africa to refer

to a village “perceived as backward or unappealing.”

That characterization drew no dissent from us at the time. But, Old Dorp

might be getting its high-tech aura back, and earning the name RoboDorp.

(You’ll have to decide for yourselves whether our image become more or less

appealing.)

 

RemELSAGlogo

Remington ELSAG

 

 

The exciting law enforcement news around here last week was that our city

of 62 thousand souls now has two SPD police vehicles equipped with the

Mobile Plate Hunter 900 from RemingtonELSAG. MPH900 is at the leading

edge of license plate recognition technology. What does that mean? Mounted

atop a police vehicle, the device can:

“scan 20 license plates a second and then feed the information into

a computer database to determine if the owners are wanted for any-

thing from unpaid parking tickets and lapsed vehicle registration to

murder and robbery.” [“Plate Hunter 900 has your number,” Times

Union [Albany], April 20, 2006 (reprinted here) ]

Granted, Los Angeles, CA, had the gizmo a year ago [see “Wired.com,

Grand Theft Auto Meets Robocop,” June 17, 2005], but Old Dorp just had

its credit rating raised above Junk Bond status a week ago by Moody’s, and

this old town has not been cutting-edge in anything this Millennium. It’s no

wonder then that the media is all a-buzz: See, e.g., Fox23News; and Daily

Gazette,A high-tech hunt for scofflaws,” April 20, 2006.

 

copLightG

As its creator tells us: MPH900 not only “operates independently of officer on
board (in the background) – enhancing officer safety by keeping hands on the
wheel and eyes on the scene,” it also

“Works at patrol and highway speeds – oncoming differential speeds
of in excess of 120MPH and passing speeds in excess of 75MPH+
(truly mobile-to-mobile). LPR translates the read plate data into a
digital image, checks versus an onboard hotlist, and returns an alarm
back to the operator in milliseconds for appropriate interdiction.”


The Editorial Page of our daily newspaper, the Schenectady Gazette, was


thrilled — praising the City’s ability to recoup the $20K per unit in a matter of


months by finding ticket scofflaws, and opining:



“Being harassed for a relatively minor violation will make the


scofflaws feel less welcomed in Schenectady; and if that en-


courges them to clean up their act or get out of town, so much


the better.”


The Gazette even added:



“Now that the city has embraced this kind of gee-whiz technology,


we have a suggestion for another: red-light cameras. They’re in-


stalled on traffic signals at busy intersections, and triggered when


motorists run red lights.”



[See “Let Big Brother do more to help police,” April 21, 2006; scroll


to Reply 5]










CrazyBusyCoverN


CrazyBusy



Normally quite opinionated, the f/k/a Gang admits to having mixed feelings


about this high-tech RoboCopping. Part of me is quite pleased to think that


parking and motor-vehicle scofflaws will be under the all-seeing eye of MPH900.


And, having Old 900 checking plates so that patrol officers can keep their eyes


on more important dangers to the community is a big plus. [As part of a commun-


ity policing seminar I took two years ago, I spent a couple hours on a night shift


in a patrol car. The officer has a lot of responibility out there, and both needs and


deserves to be focused on things other than unpaid parking tickets.



tiny check As a small boy, I remember asking my dad whether


the red lights left a mark on the top of your car if you


ran a red light. I can’t remember whether I was relieved


or disappointed when I learned they didn’t.


Still, I am a bit concerned about privacy rights (not to mention the fact that


those who can park in garages are beyond MPH900’s view).

traffic cop s The Times Union article states:

“Each computer can store up to 1.5 million license plates. Police said
they expected to keep a record of all scanned license plates, even those
that don’t register a violation, in the off-chance the vehicle surfaces in
connection with a future crime. Police could then search computer files
to determine if a suspect’s car was recorded in the vicinity of a crime
scene.

“That raises concern with civil libertarians. ‘That would be a privacy
concern of ours,’ said Melanie Trimble, executive director of the New
York Civil Liberty Union’s Albany office. ‘They shouldn’t be storing infor-
mation on people who are perfectly innocent. They should wait until
the person registers a violation.’

traffic patrol

“The Police Department was undecided about how long the records would
be kept, but [SPD Lt. James] Sanders said it was likely the memory would
be erased every 30 days.


What do you think? Don’t be shy (and don’t be as lazy as Your Editor). Please


think about the issues and let us know. Maybe Albany Lawyer weblogger Warren


Redlich, who handles lots of traffic tickets in the Capital Region, including Schenectady,


will post on this topic soon, or leave a Comment here.



update (April 26, 2006): RiskProf Martin Grace isn’t worried about MPH9000


(or, is he?) See “High Tech Scofflaw Detection System,” April 26, 2006.




“tiny check” Do you need a haiku break? For a little transition, I should


tell you that it has been raining a lot in Schenectady the past


few days. I’ve been wondering how two of our Honored Guest poets,


who work here in Schenectady, at Union College, have been coping


with all these April showers. Until I find out, proefssors Hilary Tann


and Yu Chang can speak to us through their haiku and senryu:












mud season


three brown cars


at the intersection




umbrella neg



downpour


the end


of the story








work load —


low clouds


over the swollen river







spring sun
the snake and I
motionless



Hilary Tann Upstate Dim Sum (2004/II)





turning over

a dead leaf

an earthworm twitches

 

 

 

 

nesting season

I drift

a little closer

 

 

 

Starbuck’s

a man in cowboy boots

asks for latte

 

 

umbrella vert

 

 

April shower —

making small talk

under the awning

 

 

 

back on shore

the river

pouring from his swamp boots

 

Yu Chang Upstate Dim Sum (2004/II)



newspaperS



Post Thoughts: You may have noticed over the past couple years, that I


never link directly to an online version of Schenectady’s Daily Gazette. That’s


because I refuse to pay $2.95 per week for an online subscription to the Gazette.


The paper — which was once available at no cost online — can be delivered to


your home for $3.50 a week. (The subscription page even explains that “7 day


delivery” includes Sunday.) Luckily, we have a community chat website that


often posts pirated images of Gazette articles that interest me. Still, it annoys


me no end that I can get “real” newspapers online for free (like the Washington


Post and the New York Times), but the folks at the Gazette — whose Circulation


Department often calls offering 6 free weeks of home delivery, no strings attached —


want money for online access.



A post from our Region’s main media weblog Albany Eye caught me eye and


my heart last week, therefore, when its anonymous Editor said:



eyeG


“Let’s face it, most of you would sooner chop off one of your fingers

than pay for news on the web. Who can blame you —and what are

you really missing by not having The Gazette online, or the godforsaken

Amsterdam Recorder?

 

“Still, it’s frustrating that instead of figuring out how to profit from the

internet, papers like The Gazette slam shut the door. Is it possible to

make money with your newspaper on the web? Absolutely, but it takes

work. It also takes a new mindset from people who can’t get past the i

dea of you putting $.50 down on the counter. They call it a business

decision; I call it alienating your customers.”


Albany Eye even has a webpoll in the margin asking “How much are you willing


to pay to read The Gazette online?” So far, fewer than 4% of respondents would


pay anything at all (and quite a few have chosen the less-polite options offered in


the poll).











false dawn


the paperboy hits


the snooze button



dagosan



Since the Gazette now offers “free” Saturday and Friday home delivery with its $1.50


Sunday subscription (which I do get for the comics, coupons and ad circulars), it


seems that the management wants more eyeballs badly. The web version is an exact


replica of the print edition. Albany Eye is right that, with a little work, The Gazette


should be able to make a profit from its website. With its grander competitor, the


Albany Times Union, offering a considerable amount of its content for free online, it is


difficult to figure out the Gazette‘s decision to hide behind an online subscription wall.



It’s going to be hard to shake our Old Dorp “backwards” image, even with new RoboDorp


gadgets, if search engines can’t even get to our newspaper of record. Does your home-


town newspaper have free online access? Does online availability keep you from buying


the hardcopy edition? Does f/k/a erode its readership everytime it mentions Schenectady?




p.s. She doesn’t use purple prose, but she sure does use purple: It’s Brandy Karl


and she’s hosting Blawg Review #54 at her bk! weblog this week.



traffic cop sf


April 15, 2006

what did lawyer-felon Capoccia give up for Lent? [twerpEsq update]

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 11:45 am

The Good News for convicted lawyer felons: Freely share your
legal expertise while incarcerated and you will be (a) very
popular with fellow inmates and (b) the recipient of many
bartered small luxuries (e.g., strawberry cereal bar, sandals,
a set of headphones, a pillow), which you will appreciate far
more than in your heyday scamming millions from clients.

tiny check Since your “clients” have no money to pay the
legal fees of private lawyers on the outside, you
won’t even have to worry about the “consumer
protection” — Unauthorized Practicezealots
at the state bar coming after your disbarred butt.


Capoccia1999
FBP inmate 06-00370



The Bad News for convicted lawyer felons: Besides losing
your freedom, you eat far too much “mystery meat,” even
though you sent in an order for “aglio con olio, broccoli rabe
and escarole salad.”

at the end of Lent the taste of you
Jim Kacian from Taboo Haiku

The Albany Times Union offers an interesting look at the prison
life of Andrew F. Capoccia, “once a fierce litigator who earned
millions from personal-injury cases before being sent off to prison
in February. “Once a big litigator; now works for food: Inmate Andrew
F. Capoccia trades legal advice for small luxuries,” by Alan Wechsler,
April 13, 2006. (We’ve chronicled Capoccia antics with his debt-reduc-
tion scam, and the gross failure of NYS bar grievance committees to
protect his clients, frequently at this weblog — see, especially, this essay.)

The source of the article is:

“a 16-page letter to a friend that was provided to the Times Union.
The prison memoir, sent last month, is penned in tone of a man who has accepted his sentence of more than 15 years with a keen sense of irony and dark humor.”

It’s well worth a deterrent look, but hurry, as the TU only keeps its content
available for free online for 7 days.

jailbird neg

raindropS Honored Guest Jim Kacian has always
been a free man:

the place i can’t reach itches your absence


passing the jug
the warmth
of many hands





first page

of the new journal

untrammeled snow


raindropS raindropS





sharp wind

the metal gate bangs shut

bangs shut









sundown —


one dog starts


them all





Jim Kacian from from Presents of Mind (1996)


except:


“sundown” – Upstate Dim Sum 2001/II


“the place” – Simply Haiku (2003)




potluck



“emptypocketsS” A little more local-area law news. Experienced litigator and appellate


advocate L. John Van Norden has been Deputy Corporation Counsel for the City of


Schenectady, NY, the past two years (and carrying most of the load for his boss,


Alfred Goldberger). He’s also an avid member of the Adirondack Forty-Sixers. John


had worked for the City for eleven years prior to entering private practice in 2001. He


left because he disagreed with the City’s policy of defending every police officer accused


of misbehavior.



The Gazette reports today that John is looking for a new job, after getting caught in the


midst of salary squabbling aimed primarily at our Mayor, which has lost him a promised


pay hike. (Daily Gazette, “City’s Counsel Seeking New Job,” April 15, 2006). What


I wanted to point out is that John made only $45,000 in salary for his fulltime job for


2005. In order to get a raise to $70,000 for 2006, his boss allowed his own Corporation


Counsel salary to be cut from $70,000 to $50,000, as of Jan. 1, 2006. Those who think


that only losers take municipal law jobs, and/or that all lawyers are overpaid, should


take a look at John Van Norden’s record. We wish him the best as he looks for a new


position.



bully flip



Another Schenectady story that may be of interest to Web denizens is the arrest of


David R. Monty, who is accused of stalking his estranged wife using several techniques


involving the internet:



– Sending harassing emails to his wife and her employer


and friends; they placed the wife in fear of bodily harm


and caused her employer of eight years (a cardiology


office) to fire her.



– Creating a weblog that he pretended was his wife’s web-


site. The weblog had “vulgar and sexual entries”.



bully



– Attempting to access his wife’s bank accounts online.



– Illegally using wireless internet access points: stealing


the signals from his neighbors, allegedly, to avoid paying


for the services.


In April 2004, Monty wrote a Letter to the Editor to the Schenectady


Gazette, complaining that having to disclose a 1998 conviction for


“first-degree harassment” prevented him from being hired for jobs.


He wrote “Come on, employers, is there nothing in your past that


you have done that may be questionable? Give some of us a chance


to prove we are citizens.” (Daily Gazette [Schenectady, NY], “Police


say man stalked wife via Internet,” A1, by Steven Cook, April 15, 2006,


available by subscription)



tiny check To the best of my recollection, Mr. Monty was the


person who first taught me — while representing a child


as Law Guardian in Family Court — that keeping a mother


safe is a necessity for keeping a child safe. Sadly, when


a mother chooses to remain in a violent relationship, she


puts her children at risk



blackboardAdd



Fibonacci/Schmibonacci: You won’t get the f/k/a Gang to start


counting syllables again. See “is it or ain’t it haiku?” (via Blawg Review)




update (10 PM): Jonathan Stein of The Practice weblog has written yet another mouse lawyer small


attack on me and my position regarding the ethics of the standard contingency fee.


See “Bonus Post: One More freaking time,” April 15, 2006. For the third time, he has


failed to link to any of my materials on the topic (such as this). This time, Jonathan calls


my analysis is “crap” and “hateful”, and asserts again that only a p/i lawyer can have


an opinion about the ethics of contingency fees — especially the position that fees should


vary according to the lawyers perceived risk at the time of entering the fee agreement. So


far, he hasn’t explained why the American Trial Lawyers Association submitted a statement


to the Utah Supreme Court, in 2003, explaining [at 12]:





” ‘Attorneys should exercise sound judgment and use a percentage in the


contingent fee contract that is commensurate with the risk, cost, and effort


required.’ . . . The passage is not merely information given to clients, but is


taken verbatim from a resolution on professional ethics regarding the use of


contingent fees, adopted by ATLA’s Board of Governors in 1986. This resolu-


tion continues to be ATLA’s policy regarding the ethical obligations of its


members.” [emphasis added]



[ed. note: ATLA says the appropriate percentage belongs in the fee


contract. No client should have to depend on the lawyer giving him a


a fee rebate at the end of the case.]


mouse lawyer horiz Admittedly, we are experiencing an illicit Easter Eve Chocolate-Bunny


Overdose right now, and may be more annoyed than usual by his pixel drivel. However, we’re


writing because poor Jonathan needs some mentoring. Would someone who cares about


him, please remind Jonathan that potential clients for his Elk Grove, CA, solo practice just


might Google him and discover his attitudes and EQ? Couldn’t someone more objective than


I, let Mr. Stein know that he will soon be known, throughout weblawgdom, as twerpEsq, if he


doesn’t stop these little temper tantrums. In the holiday spirit, someone go hug Mr. Stein.




in the farm field
his wife hides…
croaking frog



Issa, translated by David G. Lanoue





jailNeg




March 6, 2006

today, all poetry is local (punditry, too)

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 7:12 pm

In a manner of speaking, the very best haiku are all

“local” — they are “right here,” rooted in the immediate nexus

of the poet with the things around him or her.

 

However, I’m using “local” in this post in its more pedestrain,

geographical meaning. On a beautiful early-March day, I want

to share poems from four haijin who live close by. I hope Yu, Hilary,

John and Tom got to enjoy that blue sky and gauzy moon, with

those moderating temperatures, as I did.

 

sunglassesG

 

 

daybreak —

the spider centered

in its web

 

 

 

 

no mirror

above the sink —

I look at the wall

 

Tom Clausen, frogpond (XXIX:1 Winter 2006)

 

 

mausoleum —
just passing
through

runners black small

college photos
out of the shoe box
a dry apple core

Yu Chang, The Heron’s Nest (Vol. VIII: 1, March 2006)
mausoleum” and “college photos

after sunset . . .

the shapes

of the clouds

 

 

sweet grapes
the conversation passes
between friends

approaching winter
the fragrance of herbs
under sweet straw

threeQuarterMoon Hilary Tann
approaching winter” & “sweet grapes
“after sunset” – (Museum of Haiku Literature Award, from Frogpond XXVIII:3)

cold night
the dashboard lights
of another car

“slicingThePie”

late night —
a waitress repeats
the list of pies

John Stevenson The Heron’s Nest (Vol. VIII: 1, March 2006)
click for “late night” & cold night

potluck

tiny check The politicians in Schenectady have been acting stupidly again, but

I’d like to spotlight a pair of citizens who did something about it and

scored a victory against City Hall — even though their elected leaders

did not give them credit, when giving in.

 

“spotlightS”

 

The major’s job in Schenectady pays $60,5000, which is probably low,


when the headaches of running a financially downtrodden small city


are considered. Nonetheless, when running for the top office in a City


facing a very large budget deficit, our Mayor Brian U. Stratton promised


(in a candidate debate) that he would not accept any pay raise that went

into effect during the current term of office, should one be voted by the City

Council (which is controlled by his Democratic Party). There was no

mention of a mayoral pay raise when last year’s budget was presented

and adopted. However, a few weeks later, the City Council voted a 46%

pay increase for the mayor, to $88,000 — effective during the current

mayoral term.

 

A lot of citizens were appalled by the duplicity. Two of them, Pat

Zollinger and Vince Riggi, went to work in late December. As a result,

Mayor Stratton announced last week that he was ending the effort to

increase his salary prior to the end of his term (Dec.30, 2007) . But,

even that reversal was done in a way that leaves a bad taste.

 

strock

 

As Schenectady Gazette columnist Carl Strock put it, giving his

Award for Civic Achievement to Zollinger and Riggi (“No raise OK, but

why kill the petition?”, March 5, 2006, B1; available here):

“After the mayoral raise was so sneakily adopted,

they researched the law and discovered that the enabling

legislation was subject to what is known as a permissive

referendum, if people would only petition. . . .

 

“With the deadline for a petition only a month away, Pat

and Vince scrambled to collect signatures . . . and they

ended up with what seemed like a comfortable margin,

nearly 500 more than [the required 1500].

The Mayor did not give up his fight at that time. First, he turned to

his Law Department for help to scuttle the petition. When they didn’t

pan out (apparently), Stratton hired an outside expert, Albany lawyer

Thomas Marcelle, costing the City $3500. With just a few days to de-

cide whether the petition is valid, Marcelle told the Mayor that 1255 of

the signatures should be disqualified and Stratton rejected the petition.

Nonetheless, rather than face the growing political storm and a court

challenge, Mayor Stratton decided to cut his losses and give up the

quest for an immediate pay raise.

 

“spotlightN”

 

Strock, in response to these shenanigans, noted “it did not show a

lot of class,” but the Mayor could redeem himself by writing a $3500

check to cover Marcelle’s fee, and volunteering “for a dunking booth

at a street fair this summer.” Carl concluded:

“If it hadn’t been for their [Riggi and Zollinger’s] effort,

there’s no doubt in my mind that Stratton’s backdoor

raise would have stood and we would not have seen

him surrendering the other day at City Hall.

 

“If you like street-level democracy, as I do, this was

street-level-democracy. Pat and Vince did a heck of

a job.”

 

I agree! You can get more information on this battle at Pat’s

weblog.

 

“blindfoldDude”

 

 

 

February 27, 2006

a spidey-tale in the schenectady jail

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 12:29 pm

You may have heard on Friday that the famous Wall-Crawler will be dressed

in a new black costume, in the 2007 Sony film “Spider-Man 3,” instead of his

old, nerdy red and blue suit. Here in Schenectady, NY, we had a Spidey of

our own this week, but he was dressed in bright prisoner orange. [articles

and local comment collected here]

 

The Schenectady County jail is right next door to our main County Office Building

and courts, at the edge of our downtown district, and a little over a mile from my

home. Operated by the Schenectady [NY] County Sheriff’s Department (SCSD),

and Sheriff Harry Buffardi, the jail had its first escape since 1987. The story would

be rather entertaining, if it didn’t suggest quite a bit of ineptitude in an agency that

is important for public safety.

 

OrtizGaz Edwin Ortiz

photo: P.R.Barber/Gazette

 

The star of the show is 41-year-old Edwin Ortiz, who has been out of prison only

about half a year out of the last 20. When released in March 2005 from a Penn-

sylvania prison, he and his girlfriend (Rhonda L. Nickell-Spearman) went on an armed

robbery spree that ended last October in Schenectady, after a dangerous, high-speed

vehicular chase. At that time, he allegedly threatened to kill the arresting officer, saying

he would not be taken alive. His jailors soon learned that Ortiz had escaped from a

Pittsburgh juvenile detension center in 1982, using a knife to threaten his “house mother.”

After his arrest, Ortiz admitted to gun-point robberies in Herkimer County, Syracuse,

Philadelphia, New York City, Erie, Pa., and Bergen, N.J. (Newsday/AP, Feb. 22, 2006)

tiny check Sheriff Buffardi has had a distinguished career in SCSD,

rising from jail guard to Sheriff, and has written a well-regard-

ed History of the Office of Sheriff. Given Ortiz’s history, Buffardi

assured the public this week that “we had him on extraordinary

watch.”

jailNeg

 

Tuesday night, however, it was Ortiz who acted extraordinarily. From news stories,

including interviews with Ortiz after his capture, here’s a quick summary of the

tale [see “Inmate Escapes from County Jail: authorities consider man dangerous,”

Schenectady [NY] Gazettte, by Kathleen Moore, Feb. 22, 2006, $ub. only, but, repro-

duced here; “Jailbreak details provided;” Gazettte, by Steven Cook, Feb. 23, 2006, re-

produced here, at Reply 8); “Ortiz talks; Buffardi stews,” Gazettte, by Steven Cook,

Feb. 24, 2006,r eproduced here, at Reply 12); “No plan doomed fugitive: Edwin Ortiz

details desperate attempt to flee . .,” by Jordan Carleo-Evangelist, Albany [NY]

Times Union, Feb. 24, 2006; CapitalNews9, “Inmate who escaped now in police cus-

tody,” Feb. 23, 2006]:

jailFence The recreation area of the Schenectady County Jail , which is

located on the roof of the jail’s kitchen — surrounded on three sides by building

walls and on the fourth side by a fence; it is also enclosed on the top by fencing

that is 35′ above the ground.

 

About a month ago, Ortiz “noticed a flaw in a chain-link fence obscured from

the lone guard by a steel beam. An assiduous runner, Ortiz said he kicked the

fence as he jogged past everyday, jolting it free from a broken hook.” [TU] He

also began a vigorous exercise routine (running in place in his cell and deep-

knee bends, accourding to Buffardi) and a weight-loss program.

Ortiz later told the TU that he plotted to exploit a weakness in the

jail’s rooftop exercise yard, convincing himself that even plummeting to

his death in the attempt would be better than never seeing freedom again.

 

Sheriff Buffardi BuffardiH

 

According to CapitalNews9, Sheriff Buffardi “said he knew the fence

was loose in the rec yard but he never imagined an inmate could get

out.” However, Buffardi told the Gazette that “the rec fence was com-

promised and that went undiscovered.” The Sheriff assures County

residents that fences will now be checked regularly.

At 5:08 PM, on Feb. 21, 2006, Ortiz and a group of prisoners were escorted to the

jail’s recreation area. Ortiz recalled to the TU reporter:

As dusk approached Tuesday “I paced the yard for a couple of minutes to

hype myself up for the jump,” Ortiz said, knowing what was ahead. Then

he slipped his fit, 5-10 frame through the hole and scaled the cage unseen

by anyone except fellow inmates, authorities said.

 

OrtizTU Edwin Ortiz

by Lori Van Buren/Times Union

 

Standing on top, 35 feet above the pavement, Ortiz said he briefly contem-

plated the 10-to-12-foot gap that separated him from the roof of an old

dormitory. He stepped back a few feet and made a running leap, crashing

onto the adjacent roof and spraining his ankle. He then had to scramble

to different levels of that roof to reach its lowest point, where his grip slipped

and he fell 12′ straight to the ground, again hurting his ankle — an injury that

would hobble him during his tour of the “Electric City.”

Like the “real” comics-movie Spiderman, who often acts without a plan (or enough

spidey-web), Ortiz found himself “A fugitive in a strange city, injured and searching for

railroad tracks so he could hop the first train ‘anywhere out of Schenectady’.” Also,

like Spidey, he shrugged out of his work clothes and was running around in under-

wear (wearing a sweat shirt, long johns and boxer shorts). Oritz says he had no

inside or outside help, and merely found (in a bag on State Street, our main down-

town thoroughfare) the jeans, jacket and other clothes he was wearing when captured.

Sheriff Buffardi is quoted saying: “We did not anticipate that he could make

this miraculous spider-man-like jump from the top of the recreation area to

the top of another building 12 feet away.” (CapitalNews9, Feb. 22, 2006)

 

Buffardi told the Gazette: “I can understand his reluctance to divulge the

people who were helpful to him.”

handcuffsG

 

Ortiz hobbled off, after his escape, believing that he probably had a 15-minute head

start. However, he didn’t realize that he was dealing with SCSD. Here’s what was

going on inside the jail:

6:12 p.m: the other inmates were escorted back to their cell blocks from

the rec yard and an officer recorded Ortiz to be back on the floor

 

– that same officer, who was required to make his count by visual

inspection of each inmate, recorded Ortiz (who was, after all, “on

extraordinary watch”) as present in the cell block 5 additional times

in the next hour

 

7:15 p.m: according to the officer’s log, he finally realized that he was

one man short.

escapeCount

“Forty-two, forty-fwee plus one missing,

that makes forty-four!” [Gazette, Feb. 26, 2006

orig. at 14]

7:38 p.m. : said officer gets around to notifying his supervisor of the

problem

“tinyredcheck” Because Ortiz had supposedly come in from the rec yard, and

no one could conceive of an escape off that roof, almost three

hours were spent looking inside the jail for Ortiz. “We took apart

every wiring conduit. We had to get keys to locks we haven’t

opened in years,” Buffardi said. . . . “Then we found the breach

in the recreation yard fence,” and realized they had an escape.

(Gazette, Feb. 22, 2006, B1)

9 p.m.: neighboring police departments alerted;

 

10:15 p.m.: general alarm sounded of the escape

Ortiz9

 

Although Schenectadians went to bed Tuesday night, and awoke Wednesday

morning, knowing that a dangerous felon was at large, the Schenectady Gazette

went to bed with an edition that told of the danger in a lengthy story, but did not

bother to run a picture of Edwin Ortiz. TV stations did run photos on their local

news shows on Tuesday night.

 

The residents of Schenectady County were lucky. Ortiz had escaped into a city

he did not know, where he had no personal contacts; he was also very cold and

confused. (When he found the apartment of a girlfriend of one of his prison-mates,

she slammed the door in his face and told him where he could find some Puerto

Ricans) Nineteen hours after his escape, Ortiz was captured, only ten blocks from

the jail, and without injuries to the arresting officers. He apparently committed no

crimes while loose. [You can see a video interview in which Ortiz says the brief

escape was worth it. WNYT13, Feb. 23, 2006]

 

Luckily, Ortiz had no guns or other weapons. He told the Times Union reporter:

“I wish I would have had a gun yesterday. Just to shoot it out … to get

lucky and not have to face it anymore. . . . Guys who are facing the rest

of their lives in jail, I don’t know what holds them back.”

jailNeg

 

The TU reporter got it right:

In addition to a cinematic jailbreak story, Ortiz’ 19-hour vanishing

act has left serious questions about security at the downtown jail.

Chief among them is how a veteran guard counted Ortiz as being

in his cell block six times in the hour after he’s now believed to

have escaped.

At this point, both an internal investigation and one by the state Commission of

Correction are continuing. Sheriff Buffardi says that any disciplinary action against

the [so far unnamed] guard, who repeatedly miscounted the inmates, and others,

would stem from those investigations.

 

update (March 3, 2006): See quick, count to six, to learn that deputies Gerald

Treacy and Jayme Paul were fired for their negligent counting, and more. Per the

Gazette (“Sheriff fires 2 after jail escape,” by Steve Cook, March 2, 2006, repro-

duced here, reply 15):






“There were supposed to be six inmates on Ortiz’s


tier, [Sheriff Harry] Buffardi emphasized.



‘I don’t think it’s a difficult or tremendous burden


for us to require a count to six people,‘ Buffardi said.”

 

jailbird neg

 

 

Prison fence:
the razor wire glints
with first light

 

George Swede Simply Haiku (Sept. 2003, I:3)


restored prairie . . .
where the grasses end
the prison’s outer fence

postal chess —
he moves me
from his cell

rook horiz

winter sun begins
to warm the steering wheel
prison visit day

another Christmas . . .
my parents visit
the son in prison

lee gurga from Fresh Scent (1998)

SpiderManBlackF

 

February 3, 2006

Capoccia gets 15 years for swindling clients

Filed under: lawyer news or ethics,pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 6:25 pm

[updated: Feb. 4, 2006] After merely slapping the wrists of two cooperating

co-conspirators, U.S. District Court Judge J. Garvan Murtha sentenced dis-

barred lawyer Andrew J. Capoccia to 188 months imprisonment, for stealing

millions of dollars from thousands of clients, through his “debt reduction”

centers in New York and in Vermont. (WNYT.com, “Attorney gets over 15 years

for cheating clients;” Associated Press, “Capoccia sentenced to 15 years;”

Feb. 3, 2006) Albany Times Union‘sHis debt is 188 months in prison,by

Alan Wechler; Rutland Herald‘s “Fraud mastermind gets 15-plus years in prison,”

by Daniel Barlow, Feb. 4, 2006.]

 

From his bench in Rutland, Vermont, Judge Murtha Murtha called Capoccia’s

crimes “horrendous” because they targeted victims who were trying to avoid

bankruptcy and because he purposely surrounded himself with “weak” asso-

ciates he could control and intimidate to maintain his fraudulent practices.”

 

scales rich poor

 

Judge Murtha stated:

“This is judgment day as far as I’m concerned, Mr.

Capoccia.”

The TU reported that: “Before the sentencing, Vermont attorney [Tom]

Zonay made a passionate appeal to the judge, first asking that Capoccia

be sentenced to only two years in prison, and then asking that he be re-

leased after sentencing to allow him to work on an appeal. ‘He shouldn’t

be detained today,’ Zonay said. ‘There’s just no reason for it.’ Murtha

disagreed.

“He victimized thousands of people. He knew what he was

doing . . . As far as I’m concerned, Mr. Capoccia has no respect

for the law.”

“Murtha ended with an optimistic word for the man who will likely be in his

late 70s when he exits prison. ‘He has many talents,” Murtha said of

Capoccia. ‘Hopefully when he gets out of prison, he will be able to use those

talents’.”

 

Capoccia1999

Andrew J. Capoccia (1999)

Rutland Herald

 

Capoccia was convicted in April 2005 on conspiracy, laundering and fraud

charges. According to the Albany Times Union (“Capoccia sentence,” Feb.

3, 2006):

“Capoccia had asked in a motion filed Wednesday not to be

sent away immediately, in order to work on an appeal. But

Murtha said he didn’t think an appeal would have merit, and

he also indicated he didn’t expect any of the Capoccia con-

victions to be reversed.

 

“Capoccia sold his debt-reduction firm to lawyers in Bennington in

2000. Three years later, the Law Centers closed, leaving thousands

of clients who had paid money to have their debts resolved in even

more debt.”


In addition to jail time, Capoccia will have three years of supervised release


and must make restitution of more than $7.26 million. He also must give 10


percent of all earnings after his release to victims. Three other co-defendants


have been ordered to pay more than $800,000 in restitution.



Prosecutors had asked for a sentence of 360 months in prison, or 30 years.


During Friday’s hearing, Zonay pointed out that others charged in the case had


received little or no jail time. [Ed. note: Howard Sinnott and Thomas Daly, both


disbarred lawyers, were given 3-months and one-month imprisonment, respec-


tively; Jerry Forkes, the former executive director of the Law Centers, and the


first co-defendant to enter into a plea arrangment, was sentenced to two years’


probation and ordered to pay $20,000 restitution.]



jailbird neg



According to the Times Union, Assistant U.S. Attorney Gregory Waples pointed


out that the other defendants had pleaded guilty and testified against Capoccia.



“Their criminality, while substantial, is absolutely dwarfed by what


Mr. Capoccia did,” Waples said. “They seemed truly, genuinely contrite.


Mr. Capoccia, by contrast, is unrepentant.”

Waples, in the Herald story, described Capoccia as a white-collar criminal who

abused the trust of his clients by stealing their “children’s education savings and

mortgage payments.” “They went to Mr. Capoccia for help and only suffered

more,” he said.

 

AAG Waples told the judge Friday that prosecutors are still determining the number

of victims in the case and the total amount stolen. He estimated there to be more

than 5,000 victims found so far and the financial fraud total to be close to $23 million.

Waples said some of the restitution will come from nearly $3 million prosecutors

seized from accounts held by Capoccia’s wife. (Rutland Herald, Feb. 4, 2006)

 

“tinyredcheck” Although this may seem like a wonderful victory for justice, please take a

look at my lengthy treatment of this entire “debt reduction” matter in the

essay “blame bar counsel for letting Capoccia harm clients” (March 8, 2005).

As I lamented (with details) last year:

This lawyer scandal and client catastrophe could have been avoided —

minimized and stopped in its tracks — if bar counsel acted responsibly

and competently when the first barrage of suspicious ads came out in

1997; or when they received detailed complaints from myself, a member

in good standing of the bar [starting in Dec. 1997]; or when they were

flooded with client complaints (which at first were not even accepted, but

were instead referred to the State Attorney General’s office); or when news-

paper and tv reports emerged about angry and injured clients.

 

“doghouseN”

 

Or, or, or . . Instead, toothless and blind watchdogs did nothing, while their

cousin the wolf (with main offices on Wolf Rd. in Colonie, NY) plundered the

flock. There is little chance of reimbursement for the cheated clients and

many may never be able to repair their bad credit.

 

Because the debt reduction behavior was never challenged by the Grievance

Committees [he was disbarred for bringing frivolous lawsuits and ignoring court

orders], Capoccia’s partners were able, at their “Law Centers for Consumer

Protection,” to continue attracting and bilking clients — some say up to 20,000.

My first complaints against Capoccia were made when he was claiming to have

“helped hundreds of clients.”

I’m pleased that Judge Murtha has finally given a serious sentence in this case, but I’m

still angry on behalf of the unnecessarily injured clients and the unnecessary additional

blot on the reputation of lawyers. Effective lawyer discipline — especially the willingness

to investigate clearly excessive contingency fees* — would have saved a lot of people a

lot of misery.

 

* What made this scheme so lucrative for Capoccia was his

fee system. He said that he took “only” 25 or 27% of the

amount of debt reduction achieved for the client. In actuality,

he took the entire fee — usually thousands of dollars — up

front, before doing anything for the client, and calculated it

on the basis of clearly optimistic outcomes (predicting the

ability to reduce debts by 50 to 75%). If that scheme, which

clearly violated ABA Formal Ethics Opinion 93-373 (regarding

“reverse” contingency fees, which are based on savings, rather

than winnings), and ABA Formal Opinions 94-389, had been

declared unethical, there would have been no incentive for

Capoccia to continue providing his “service.”

 

you look too
robber! dewdrops
in the grass




Issa,


translated by David G. Lanoue



scales rich poor neg



January 30, 2006

admonish D.A. DeAngelis

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 7:15 pm

Never having been a public defender, I’m not a kneejerk hater of prosecutors.

However, I can’t let another day go by without saying that a series of con-

victions overturned due to prosecurtorial misconduct in Rensselaer County

[Troy], New York, is shameful and can only weaken the public’s trust in our

justice system.


courthouseS


In the latest case, involving defendant Burton Jeffrey Hunter, the district

attorney’s office failed to inform the defense, in an acquaintance rape case,

that then-17-year-old victim had accused another man she knew of rape only

two or three weeks before Hunter’s trial. [That’s two such charges within

eleven months. In addition, the “victim’s” father testifeid at trial that she had

accused him of rape when he tried to discipline her. Troy Record, Jan. 26,

2006] Hunter was convicted of sodomy, and has spent the past four years

in jail.

tiny check The fact of the second accusation came to light last year,

when Hunter’s trial lawyer, Paul DeVane was working out a

plea bargain for Delbert Parker, a Schenectady man convicted

of armed burglary and charged with rape. Parker told DeVane

that he had been accused of rape just before Hunter’s trial, by

the same young woman.

Current Rensselaer District Attorney Patricia DeAngelis was not D.A.

at the time of the trial, but was an ADA and had presented the case

to the grand jury. “[S]ources familiar with the case say she did most,

if not all, of the pre-trial work and then handed the case over to another

prosecutor.” (WTEN.com, Jan. 25, 2006).


mjudge


When the issue was raised last year, trial judge Patrick McGrath agreed to

hear arguments for a newtrial, because the prosecution “failed to deny or

admit actual knowledge” of the material that could assist the defense. De-

Angelis was (unsuccessfully) running for county judge at the time and asked

for several extensions to answer the allegation. Not until Dec. 28, a few

days before the argument on the new trial, did she finally fax a stipulation to

Hunter’s counsel, saying that former prosecutor Mark Portin, who succeeded

DeAngelis on the case, never disclosed the victim’s subsequent allegation to

Hunter’s lawyer. (Albany Times Union, Jan. 5, 2006)

tiny Red Check At the time of the hearing, I recall DeAngilis telling a tv reporter that

her office considered the fact of the second accusation to be “infor-

mation” but not evidence that had to be disclosed.

Judge McGrath disageed, ruling that Assistant District Attorney Mark Portin

improperly failed to inform Hunter’s attorney of the second accusation. Accord-

ing to the Troy Record (Jan. 26, 2006): Judge McGrath wrote:

“A prosecutor should not intentionally avoid pursuit of evidence

merely because he or she believes it will damage the prosecutor’s

case or aid the accused. . . A prosecutor has a duty to seek justice

and not merely to convict.”

McGrath noted that the “victim” was the only person who had direct knowledge

of the event and that establishing her credibility was paramount to a just verdict.

The Judge continued: “Surely, in the context of this case the People knew the un-

disclosed Brady material would have been useful to the defense. The only reason

not to divulge it would be for the People to gain some tactical and unfair advantage

that clearly violates the People’s professional responsibility.” Therefore, “The People

should be admonished for their failure to disclose the Brady information.”


None of this was persuasive to D.A. DeAngelis, who told the press: “While my

position on this matter has not changed as to our obligation to disclose this information,

the decision of the court is now the law in this county, and obviously we will prosecute

future cases in line with the court’s decision.” Two other sex abuse convictions were

recently overturned due to the misconduct or incompetence of DeAngelis’ office, along

with a fourth major conviction.


newspaperS


An editorial titled “Enough, Ms. DeAngelis” (Jan. 27, 2006), the Albany Times Union

called for the D.A. to step down, saying it quite well:

Justice is a more tenuous concept than ever today in Rensselaer

County, upheld by Judge Patrick McGrath but undermined by District

Attorney Patricia DeAngelis. It’s a familiar but depressing pattern, of

unfair and inept prosecution that requires judges to reverse convictions

obtained by the district attorney’s office or, in the latest such case, to

order a new trial for a man convicted of sodomy after critical evidence

was withheld from his defense lawyer.


When does it end? Only when Ms. DeAngelis steps aside as district

attorney. . . .


… Ms. DeAngelis has quite a bit less to say [than Judge McGrath] about

the denial of such an essential right of Mr. Hunter’s. Just like [tial ADA

Mark ] Portin, she doesn’t think the evidence that was withheld was

relevant to Mr. Hunter’s trial.


Her reaction to the vacating of Mr. Hunter’s conviction amounts to yet

another strike against Ms. DeAngelis and her office’s reckless approach

to criminal prosecution. The Appellate Division of the state Supreme Court

has reversed convictions obtained by Ms. DeAngelis or her colleagues

three times in the past two years for reasons of prosecutorial errors or

misconduct.


coyote moon small


How much longer must the people of Rensselaer County put up with such

ignorance of the law in, of all places, the district attorney’s office? The same

voters who so wisely rejected Ms. DeAngelis’ candidacy for a judgeship of

her own last year remain stuck with her as county prosector.


“The prosecution has a duty to seek justice and not merely convict,” notes

Judge McGrath.


Such a reasonable statement, such a far-fetched notion.

I’m not as sure as the TU that the D.A.’s Office has made these mistakes out of

ignorance or incompetence. A former ADA is suing the D.A.’s Office, saying she

was fired for complaining about unethical conduct. Two days after the order was

issued for the new trial, Ms. DeAngelis had this statement:


coyote moon sn

“My number one responsibility as District Attorney is to ensure that

justice is served. My office has a conviction rate of 98 percent. This

is the result of a talented and dedicated staff who take their duty to

protect the citizens of Rensselaer County seriously.” (Capital9News,

Albany, NY, Jan. 27, 2006)

Justice 101: Convictions do not always equal justice. Overzealousness doesn’t assure justice. Often it prevents it.

tiny check After another dreary-gray winter day, I deserve some Tom Painting haiku — and so do you:


storm warning
the watercolorist works
in shades of grey












skaterSignG









paint by number


the child’s river


escapes its bank











winter dusk
she paints her nails
deeper red




“bigToe”








false dawn
a ruffed grouse drums
the woods awake









spring plowing
a flock of blackbirds
turns inside out






Tom Painting


winter dusk” – The Heron’s Nest (2003)


storm warning” from The Heron’s Nest


“paint by number” – tug of the current: RMA 2004


false dawn” – The Heron’s Nest


crayonBoxV



January 28, 2006

renku’d into submission

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 11:58 pm

John Stevenson and Yu Chang introduced me to the poetic genre

of renku today — the short-form Junicho Renku, with twelve stanzas

of linked verses written by a group of poets. Although I literally had

never read an entire renku, Yu and John insisted that I start writing ths

highly-structured, over-regulated (many, many rules) genre over lunch

and, eventually, dinner.

tiny check At the bottom of this post, you will find a brief

description of Renku from the Haiku Society of America.

You can find links to sample renku and much information

about the genre at William J. Higginson’s Renku Home.

 

sumoS

 

With sturm und angst (and a Thai dinner in an old German Bierhaus

located in downtown Schenectady), we produced twelve verses that

actually fit together rather well (I am still not at all sure what makes

a renku “good”).. We’re going to do some polishing.

 

It seems I survived, but I barely got home in time to post some haiku before turning into a pumpkin at midnight.

(update: Sheer Irony: the resulting poem, “Chinese New Year”, was selected as the 1st Place winner in the 2006 Einbond Renku Competition, of the Haiku Society of America; see our post)

 

Here are a pair each from John and Yu, along with my thanks for their guidance and patience:

 

 

children’s gardens
all the scarecrows
dressed like mom

another winter
nursing
the furnace

………………….. by John Stevenson

 

– Upstate Dim Sum (2004/I)

 

 

 

 

 


rough landing
the warmth
of your hand

wishing well
a borrowed coin lands
on the bronze monkey


…………… by
Yu Chang Upstate Dim Sum (2004/I)

 

 

 

 

 


dog black Happy Chinese New Year! The Year of the Dog!

dog tired —
no laurels
to rest on

………… dagosan

HSALogo From the Haiku Society of America Definitions page:

RENKU Definition: A renku is a linked-verse poem in the popular haikai style, particularly as practiced by Basho and later poets writing in his style.

Notes: In Japanese, “renku” is a modern equivalent for haikai no renga. Usually written by two or more people, a renku’s most important features are linking and shifting. “The best English approximation of the verse-rhythm of Japanese renku seems to be a poem . . . beginning with a three-line stanza, followed by a two-line stanza, and alternating three- and two-line stanzas thereafter. This parallels the gentle longer/shorter/longer rhythms basic to renku in Japanese . . . .”

Typical renku consist of eighteen, twenty, thirty-six, or more of these alternating stanzas, though even shorter forms have been popular in recent decades. “Note that the starting verse of a renku is what evolved into the ‘haiku’ as we know it, with its emphasis on the here and now. The remaining stanzas . . . should connect well with their preceding stanzas and provide opportunity for movement in a new direction for those following. . . . A major point of renku writing is to move forward, from stanza to stanza, through a great variety of time, weather, environment, activity,fauna, and flora. . . .

Stanzas focused on human activities and concerns should be balanced throughout with stanzas concentrating on landscapes, animal and plant life, and other subject matter.” (Quoted material from the “Report of the HSA Renku Contest Committee”, published in Frogpond XIII:2, May 1990, which contains more detailed guidelines for traditional-style renku and a bibliography of materials on the subject.)

computer weary

January 16, 2006

snow bocce update — Haijin Snow Bocce Festa

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 7:29 pm

We’ve got big news for fans of bocce, snow and haiku: the
first-ever New York Capital Region Haijin Snow Bocce Festa
was held on Sunday, January 8, 2006, in Schenectady’s Central
Park. To our knowledge, it was the first all-Haijin Snow Bocce
event on this (or any) continent (or island).

[“haijin” are people who write haiku and related literary forms.]

BocceBallsN

Participants were

John Stevenson of Nassau, NY. JStevenson
who is editor of Frogpond.

YChang Yu Chang of Schenectady, founding
member of the Route 9 Haiku Group (along with
John Stevenson and Hilary Tann), and

f/k/a’s editor, David Giacalone [a/k/a dagosan], boy writing
also of Schenectady, NY.

Preparation for the competition portion of the Snow Bocce Festa
included a long lunch, at the home of Yu Chang, near the Park,
featuring Chinese dumplings that were prepared, along with other
delicacies, by Professor Chang.

bocci The actual bocce competition was an adventure, as none
of the players had previous experience with snow bocce. Conditions
in a thinly wooded section of the park were optimal, with varying sur-
faces — both smooth and uneven ice and both powdery and ice-
crusted snow. There was three to six inches of snowpack, and little
wind.

Some observations:

– the game was, at the same time, very much like and
very much different from traditional “informal” lawn bocce.
– no special rules were adopted for play on snow
– the pallino was often difficult to see (except by John) snowflakeS
– the bocce balls, as might be expected, skidded on
ice and made nice, round, deep holes in soft and ice-
crusted snow
snowflakeS – a passing bocce ball can often cover the pallina with
a spray of snow
– unlike play on lawns or courts, balls can sit atop
each other in snow bocce, raising interesting measuring
issues
– putting backspin on the ball was often useful
– it didn’t take too long to get used to wearing gloves,
and to playing with cold hands and feet

Yu brought a mini-video camera, which did nothing to improve the quality of play, but did memorialize portions of the contest, which dagosan eventually won.

USBFLogoF

Despite the participation of two veteran and one newbie journey-

man haiku poets, the competition has not yet inspired a rash of

poetry (or, perhaps, John and Yu are saving them for publication

in their Upstate Dim Sum journal). As they are produced by

dagosan and submitted by Yu Chang and John Stevenson, they

will be shared with f/k/a‘s audience and added to this posting.

Snow Bocce Festa –
my back remembers
more than my brain

dagosan

 

snow bocce
left the pooper scooper
at home


dagosan at simply senryu



 

snowflakeS The Festa was unanimously declared a success, and future Snow

Bocce Festa will be staged. We hope to entice Hilary Tann, Tom

Clausen and other haikuists to join the fun — and the agita.

winter evening

a cafeteria tray

at the end of the slope

Yu Chang

Upstate Dim Sum 2003/I

 

 

first snow

what a racket

from the geese

John Stevenson

from Quiet Enough

p.s. It’s cool, but it’s not fluffy. Check out

Blawg Review #40, hosted by Anita Campbell at her

award-winning Small Business Trends weblog. Good

stuff.

USBFLogo

January 12, 2006

too dam personal

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 7:20 pm


The Gilboa Dam, at the Schoharie Reservoir in Schoharie County NY, is


about 60 miles west of my home in Schenectady. The dam is owned by


the distant City of New York, and supplies about 16% of the NYC’s water.


For the past few months, I’ve been vaguely aware that a lot of people are


worried the 1927 Dam might fail, causing massive damage along its down-


stream watershed on the Schoharie Creek. In December, Sen. Chuck


Schumer urged NYC to speed up its repairs to the dam, and local Cong.


Mike McNulty joined Sens. Clinton and Schumer in asking the Army Corps


of Engineers to help get the job done quickly and right.



None of this focused my attention on that Dam. It’s on the Schoarie Creek,


and my backyard in the Schenectady Stockade is on the Mohawk River.


However, yesterday, a local tv news show made a report that did get me


focused (WRGB/CBS-Ch6 “Emergency plans for Gilboa dam,” Jan. 12,


2006):



Schenectady’s Stockade is about 60 miles from the Gilboa Dam


but if it were to fail it is not just the people in Schoharie County


who would be affected. Emergency officials in Schenectady


County are keeping a close eye on the aging Dam. If something


were to happen residents of the Stockade would only have 10 hours


to get out. County Emergency Management Coordinator, Bill Van


Hoesen . . . says the consequences if it did happen are serious.



spiltWine



It was recently revealed that the 80 year old Gilboa Dam was not up


to current safety standards. Water from the dam flows north from the


Schoharie Creek into the Mohawk River which along with spring thaws


and ice jams, makes the Stockade prone to flooding. Experts say that


if the Gilboa Dam does burst, [20] billions of gallons of water would head


straight for Schenectady flooding the streets of Front, Erie, and Broadway.



The water could even rise to nearly 240 feet above sea level, where it was


in 1914 [the highest on record; flood stage is about 212 feet]. Under the


emergency plan, though, Assistant Fire Chief Mike Dellarocco would go


door to door evacuate residents.


Okay, now I’m interested. I’m leaving in a few minutes for a Stockade Association


Meeting, where I hope to learn more. The tv reporters said that parts of the


Stockade — a Historic District of ancient homes — might be irretrievably lost. My


home is on the block that borders the River. Sometimes, one’s perspective can


change with just a tiny little fact or two. (Something a good judge and lawyer


should always keep in mind.)












 


river flood


a “For Sale” sign


on a cottage roof





George Swede from Almost Unseen





the flood’s wake—
driftwood bison
and dinosaurs



Barry George from Haiku Harvest (Jan-Feb 2003)











flood damage —


strolling


our new riparian beach



dagosan


 

dinner party
glancing up from grace
to the flood mark on the wall

 

wind and rain
the hand I reach for
in the dark

 

 

 

shimmering pines
a taste of the mountain
from your cupped hands

 

 

 

 

bitter wind …
the hand that cups the flame
aglow

 

 

 

snowed in
the wedding-ring quilt
lumpy with children

Winter night:
a spark between the tweeds
of strangers

 

 

 

 

mops and pails–

the wren goes on singing

with straw in its beak

 

 

 

Peggy LylesTo Hear the Rain (2002)

“mops and pails–” Frogpond XXVIII:2 (2005)

spiltBucketG

December 8, 2005

acerbic family court judge censured

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 10:56 am

Jo Anne Assini has been a Family Court judge for Schenectady County, NY,
where I reside, since January 2001. In those five years, I have not heard even
one positive thing about her work as a judge from lawyers or court personnel.
Instead, her foul mood and temper have been a source of regret for those who
make a living and/or seek justice, fairness, and solutions from that court. [Assini
was an Assistant District Attorney prosecuting sex crimes when I last
practiced at Family Court, and I have no memory of interactions with her.]

witch brew It was not at all surprising to learn, last week, that the NYS Commission on Judicial Conduct had filed formal charges against Judge Assini earlier this year, after receiving five formal complaints from litigants, and had concluded — based on stipulated facts and outcome — that she deserved censure for her conduct on the bench. In re Jo Anne Assini (NYSCJC, Nov. 18, 2005) (See
North Country Gazette, “Judge Assini Censured for Intemperate Behavior, Rights Violations,” Dec. 2,2005)

In addition to the frequent failure to apprise parties of their right to counsel, Judge Assini was very often rude and disrespectful to those who appeared before her. Like a bully, she was especially likely to show her foul mood to parties appearing without counsel. The SCJC opinion notes:

“Every judge has an obligation to respect and comply with the
law and to act in a manner that inspires public confidence in the
fair-mindedness and impartiality of the judiciary. . . In Family Court,
“where matters of the utmost sensitivity are often litigated by those
who are unrepresented and unaware of their rights” . . . such a duty
is self-evident and compelling. In several cases respondent violated
these ethical standards by neglecting to inform litigants of their statutory
rights and by addressing them in an intemperate, demeaning manner.”

” . . As the Commission and the Court of Appeals have repeatedly held, a pattern of failing to advise litigants of the right to counsel and assigned counsel is serious misconduct.

“The record also establishes that respondent violated her duty to be
“patient, dignified and courteous” to litigants in her court (Rules, �100.3
[B][3]). The transcripts depict a series of rude, demeaning remarks by
respondent to litigants in custody and visitation proceedings who came
to Family Court seeking a fair hearing before an impartial jurist. In one
case respondent told the litigants that she was “so bored” and “so sick”
of the case and spoke to the litigants angrily and impatiently when they
could not agree on a visitation schedule. In another case she criticized a

litigant who was wearing his college security [guard] shirt, telling him thathe looked like a “slob,” that “normal people” would have worn something “decent” and that he could buy a shirt or tie at the City Mission for fifty cents.


“It appears that respondent was particularly harsh towards unrepresented
litigants, addressing them in an intimidating, sarcastic manner. Indeed, in two cases (Charges I and IV) the parties actually discontinued their proceedings because of respondent’s impatience and discourtesy, apparently despairing of receiving a fair and just hearing in respondent’s court.”

The Commission pointed out that Judge Assini came on the 2-judge court
at a time when it was temporarily short one judge and facing a large backlog.
Nonetheless, it pointed out::

“While court congestion and the stress of dealing with a large backlog she inherited may have adversely affected respondent’s judicial performance, these factors do not excuse her demeaning comments to litigants and her disregard of important statutory procedures.

“In mitigation, we note that respondent has expressed remorse for her actions and that she now appropriately advises all statutorily eligible litigants of the right to counsel and assigned counsel.

“By reason of the foregoing, the Commission determines that the appropriate disposition is censure.”

coyote moon small Some readers will say that Judge Assini is really not much different from other judges, but I disagree — at least if my own experience is a guide. Here in Schenectady County, there have been three other Family Court judges since I arrived in 1988, and I have often been quite impressed with their judicial temperament and patience, in the face of very trying situations. Litigants who are not successful will always gripe about this or that judge, and I believe lawyers and staffers are a better gauge of a judge’s propriety on the bench. The Family Court community’s universal disappointment over Judge Assini suggests that she was indeed an outlier. Whether censure — the second most serious form of discipline for judges — is sufficient, I will leave for others to decide.

Let me make a few quick points:

  • Family Court judges need to be especially sensitive and respectful, and able to deal with parties who are under great personal stress.
  • Judges dealing with pro se litigants also need to be on their best behavior — extra training is now offered in many jurisdictions. I hope that the Internet can help make judges aware that lack of respect for litigants and displays of temper can get you disciplined — or, at least, shamed.

In a speech given when she was inducted into her high school’s Hall of Fame in 2004, Jo Anne Assini emphasized that “in order to succeed, you have to TRY. And you’ll probably have to fail, as I did so many times. You must never, never, never quit.” (“The Courage to Fail,” 2004 Niskayuna High School Graduation)

gavel neg She showed a bit of her prickly nature in the speech, when she noted ” I didn’t win any moot court competitions, though I came very close, and in senior trials, the judge told me I was too aggressive (something he didn’t tell any of the men in the competition…);”.

However, Judge Assini ended the speech with advice I hope she takes to heart now for herself. After noting that “The first time I ran for judge, I didn’t just lose, I was crushed,” she wisely points out:

“I realized that what people remembered about you was HOW you handled losing.”

The public and the legal community in Schenectady County hope Judge Assican greatly improve her behavior. If not, we hope she’ll decide that she can do more for the community and the profession off the bench.

 


contempt of court lawyer cellphone small
the lawyer hopes Her Honor
can’t read his mind

…….. by dagosan at simply senryu

December 7, 2005

introducing Hilary Tann

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 12:11 am

If you saw our sneak preview of the haiku of Hilary Tann,
on December 3rd, you can perhaps understand why we’re
so pleased to welcome Hilary as f/k/a‘s newest Honored
Guest Poet.

TannTreeG

Hilary is a founding member of the Rt. 9 Haiku Group, which
has produced the semiannual Upstate [NY] Dim Sum Journal
since 2001. In addiiton to Hilary, the exclusive four-member
group includes john stevenson, tom clausen, yu chang (who
all joined the f/k/a family during 2005). Each of the Rt.-9ers is
known for creating excellent haiku/senryu, of depth and breadth,
while maintaining a unique poetic voice. By meeting each month
for a leisurely, multi-course dim sum meal, at which haiku are pre-
sented, discussed, and sometimes revivsd, the four Rt. 9 members
have established a special artistic environment and helped nurture
the body of work presented in the Dim Sum journal. Hilary brings
— as each of her male co-members will attest — a special vitality
to their sessions and to their journal.

Underlying Hilary Tann‘s very recognizable voice is her experience
growing up in the coal-mining valleys of South Wales, which has
inspired both her poetry and her “main” artistic endeavor as a
music composer.

tiny check Professor and Former Chair of the Department of Per-
forming Arts at Union College, in Schenectady, New York,
Hilary she lives southeast of the Adirondack Mountains, on
the banks of the Hudson River, with her husband, and beloved
collie dog.

Hilary’s website bio explains:

As a composer (for Oxford University Press since 1989) her work quarter note gray
is of necessity forward-looking, shaping different futures. Her
enjoyment in reading and writing haiku stems in no small part from
the fact that haiku train her once more to be “of the moment.”

Despite her travels to Wales and around the nation and world, when her compo-
sitions are being performed, Hilary finds time to create one-breath poetry that graces
UDS, along with various anthologies, and leading journals, such as Frogpond
and The Heron’s Nest.

Here are excellent examples that I hope will make you seek out more
of Hilary’s work:



tiny check from the very first edition


of Upstate Dim Sum (2001/I):





calling


from balcony to balcony


caged birds








family visit


my parents compete


to end my sentences







crayonBoxV









first day of school


another crayon


for the sunrise









tiny check from the most recent


Upstate Dim Sum (2005/II)







in certain lights


my hands are those of


an older woman









intersection


a chance to view


distant mountains







sunMountains






hometown —


cricket field


above the coal mine




Hilary Tann



music staff


November 22, 2005

back in yu’s neighborhood

Filed under: pre-06-2006,Schenectady Synecdoche — David Giacalone @ 6:16 pm

Maybe I’m getting old and set in my ways — after any

traveling, I am always pleased to return home to Schenectady.

Today, I left Rochester quite early, in order to beat some

winter precipitation that was going to be coming at me from

both the west and the east.

 

To celebrate a safe return to rain-to-snow Schenectady,

I’m going to share a few poems from Schenectady’s most

celebrated haiku poet, Yu Chang.

 

vivid dreams

the din of a garbage truck

drives you away

 

 

 

 

back on shore

the river

pouring from his swamp boots

 

leaf gray

 

turning over

a dead leaf

an earthworm twitches

 

 

 

 

 

snowdrift

news of a missing dog

from pole to pole

 

 

Yu ChangUpstate Dim Sum (2004/II)

 

 

 

 





a wintry mix


at the bedroom window


big wet ones




[Nov. 22, 2005]


 

potluck

tiny check Even not-so-young whippersnappers like Evan Schaeffer

are apparently addicted to techno-speed, and need their

broadband to post to their weblogs. Your old f/k/a Editor

patiently accepts the delays of dial-up modems in

concocting this daily weblog buffet. RU Impressed?

 

tiny check You don’t have to be a federalist-fanatic or libertarian to

worry about the phenomenon of overcriminalization. Both

Mike Cernovich and Jeremy Richey have pointed to

Overcriminalization: The Politics of Crime, a symposium now

available in the American University Law Review (Vol. 54: 3,

2005). There are four articles, two essays and more, with

plenty of food for thought.

 

phone old

 

 

« Newer PostsOlder Posts »

Powered by WordPress